Malaysian couple to hang for murder of Indonesian maid who died of starvation
Starved maid weighed 26 kilograms when she died
A Malaysian couple was sentenced to hang for starving their Indonesian maid to death, a defence lawyer said on Friday, in the latest shocking case to spotlight abuse of domestic helpers in the region.
Isti Komariyah weighed just 26 kilograms on her death in Kuala Lumpur in June 2011 from what a court ruled was deliberate starvation, according to Malaysian media reports on the ruling issued on Thursday.
“She was 26 and weighed barely 26 kg when she was taken to the University Malaya Medical Centre with bruises and scratch marks on her back, arms and forehead,” The Star newspaper reported.
Fong Kong Meng, 58, and his wife Teoh Ching Yen, 56, consistently withheld food from Isti during the three years she worked for them, the court found.
Isti had weighed 46 kilograms when she first started working for the couple.
Defence counsel Ramkarpal Singh confirmed the sentence. He said his clients would appeal against the decision on Monday.
The case is the latest to underline growing concern over the vulnerability of millions of Indonesian, Philippine, Cambodian and other domestic workers to abuse by their employers around Asia and the Middle East.
Rights groups say countless maids work behind closed doors without adequate legal and labour protections, and shocking cases of beatings, maimings, and deaths have emerged over the years.
Hong Kong vowed last week to strengthen legal oversight over maid employment after gruesome images surfaced of injuries sustained by 22-year-old Erwiana Sulistyaningsih of Indonesia, who has been left unable to walk.
Thousands of domestic helpers took to the streets of Hong Kong in protest in January demanding justice over the case. Her employer has been arrested and charged with assault.
Saudi Arabia signed a pledge with Indonesia last month to give maids better protection, but is still under pressure from activists who want further reforms.
Malaysia alone relies on an estimated two million Indonesians who toil in plantation, construction, factory and domestic work – both legally and illegally.
A Cambodian maid was starved to death in 2012 by her Malaysian employers, earning them 24 years in jail. Cambodia had stopped sending maids a year earlier over previous abuses.
Despite a number of cases in relatively affluent Malaysia involving abuse of maids from less-developed Indonesia, domestic workers continue to arrive, drawn by economic necessity.
After Indonesia imposed a two-year moratorium on sending maids in 2009 due to a string of abuse cases, Malaysia has taken some steps towards to improve maids’ welfare, including giving them at least one day off a week and nearly doubling minimum monthly salaries to 700 ringgit (HK$1,667).
However, activists say the new rules are not adequately enforced.
“We want to be serious about human rights abuses, but the death penalty is not a proven deterrent. We cannot leave maids living in isolation with no access to aid when they face problems,” Yap Swee Seng, executive director of Malaysian rights group Suaram, said.
Indonesia estimates 400,000 women work in Malaysia as maids – about half illegally. Indonesian workers account for roughly half of all foreign labourers in Malaysia.
The neighbours’ closer scrutiny of the issue has slowed processing of legal domestic workers, causing a shortage that has fuelled the efforts of traffickers who bring in illegals, activists say.
Raja Zulkepley Dahalan, head of the Malaysian National Association of Employment Agencies, said he hoped this week’s death sentence “will restore the confidence of source countries that we are serious about tackling maid abuse”.
In some cases, maids have struck back.
A young Indonesian maid is on trial in Malaysia for allegedly killing her boss by stabbing her 42 times. Her defence says she had been abused by the employer.
Although nearly 1,000 people are on death row in Malaysia, executions have been rare in recent years.