Indian activists welcome top court ban on ‘sterilisation camps’ after deaths
Women’s health activists on Friday cheered a ruling by India’s top court ordering the government to shut down “sterilisation camps” within three years following the deaths of hundreds of largely poor rural women across the country.
In a judgment on Wednesday, the Supreme Court said 363 women died between 2010 and 2013 during or after surgery in sterilisation camps due poor management by local authorities which included doctors using dirty equipment and expired drugs.
It called on the federal government to ensure the country’s 29 states and seven union territories halt the camps, provide adequate compensation for victims and their families, and hold negligent doctors accountable.
Activists have long campaigned for better regulation of sterilisation camps – where women are gathered for mass surgeries to sever or seal their fallopian tubes – and more investment in alternative forms of contraception.
“We welcome the Supreme Court judgment which we consider a landmark one. Providing quality services to and upholding the dignity of women will now be placed strongly on the national agenda,” said Poonam Muttreja, executive director of the Population Foundation of India (PFI).
“This judgment has the potential to shape India’s family planning programme into a programme of national significance.”
India’s efforts to rein in population growth have been described as the most draconian after China. Birth rates have fallen in recent decades, but population growth is still among the world’s fastest.
According to a study by PFI, 85 per cent of the country’s family planning budget for 2013/14 was spent on promoting and conducting sterilisations on women. Only 1.5 per cent was spent on other forms of contraception.
The world’s top steriliser of women, India came under global scrutiny for its sterilisation drive in November 2014 when 15 women died and scores of others were hospitalised after surgery at a sterilisation camp in the eastern state of Chhattisgarh.
Investigations found the deaths in Bilaspur district were due to unhygienic conditions, dirty medical instruments and equipment and an overall lack of care for the patients who were poor tribal and low-caste women.
Authorities have put in place guidelines and are training health workers on conducting safe and sanitary surgeries, but incentivised, target-driven sterilisation continue.
Doctors, nurses and health workers receive cash incentives for promoting and carrying out sterilisations. Patients are also given compensation – ranging from 600 rupees (US$10) to 1,100 rupees (US$17) for tubectomies and vasectomies respectively.
The Supreme Court ruling was in response to a civil petition filed by women’s health activist Devika Biswas alleged widespread mismanagement at camps in various states.
The ruling mentioned how a doctor sterilised 53 women over a period of two hours “in an unprofessional and unethical manner” in a village school in the eastern state of Bihar in January 2012.
The sterilisations were conducted under torch light with the women laying on school desks, the surgeon did not have any gloves and there was no running water available, it said.
The patients, it added, were also not given any preoperative tests, counselling and were not aware of the potential dangers and outcomes of sterilisation.
“A sterilisation surgery does not appear to be complicated and yet several deaths have taken place across the country over the years,” said Justice Madan B. Lokur in his order.
“Undoubtedly, this needs looking into by the Government of India and the state governments and remedial and corrective steps need to be taken.”