• Thu
  • Oct 23, 2014
  • Updated: 10:35am
NewsChina Insider

Sanction-hit Russia faces similar problems to China after Tiananmen, says embassy

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 27 March, 2014, 7:48pm
UPDATED : Monday, 31 March, 2014, 11:18am

Russia is facing a similar diplomatic situation to that of China in 1989 after the Tiananmen Square pro-democracy demonstration crackdown, the Russian embassy of China said in a commentary on its website on Thursday.

The story posted on the Russian embassy of China’s Chinese-language website and microblog was commenting on the latest round of military sanctions by the West on Russia over its controversial move to annex Crimea from the Ukraine.

At the time, the United States and some European countries boycotted China over weapons exports and the exchange of military technology under the pretext of human rights violations

“What is happening in Russia at present is similar to the situation facing China after the 1989 crisis,” the commentary said. “At the time, the United States and some European countries boycotted China over weapons exports and the exchange of military technology under the pretext of human rights violations,” read the article first published by the Russian official broadcaster, the Voice of Russia.

The crisis referred to, was the months-long pro-democracy protests that saw hundreds of thousands of pro-democracy protesters gather at Tiananmen Square in central Beijing in the summer of 1989. The stand-off was eventually violently crushed by Chinese military forces, sparking fierce denunciation from around the world, and the West in particular.

Within days, the United States and a number of major European countries introduced a number of sanctions against China, including the suspension of all military collaboration and the trade in arms.

The commentary called on Russia and China to expand the two countries’ military collaboration in areas where they can complement each other, “so that they can control the damage from the sanctions by western nations that will arrive soon-or-later.”

The crackdown on the Tiananmen Square protests has since remained a taboo subject for the ruling Chinese Communist Party, which strictly prohibits any form of public discussion in public spaces. Using sophisticated online censorship methods, the government filters and deletes any information relating to the 1989 crackdown found in China’s cyberspace.

For instance, searching terms like “Tiananmen Square incident” on Sina Weibo – the microblog where the Russian embassy posted their story – return a notification that reads “search results are not displayed according to relevant regulations and policies.”

“The Chinese government will not respond to the comparison. [It will] either play down the subject, or simply evade it,” Wang Chong, a researcher of Beijing-based independent think tank Charhar Institute, told the South China Morning Post on Thursday.

Wang said China should retain its diplomatic balance between Russia and the US throughout the Crimea crisis, instead of seeking alliance with Russia to counter the US. “It’s not a right time to strengthen ties with Russia. Rather it should maximise its benefits from this diplomatic wrestle.”

Since the Crimea Crisis has been emerging in the past month, China has maintained a vague diplomatic position on the issue.

Its Foreign Ministry spokesman in the beginning of the month said China upholds the principle of non-interference in a country’s internal affairs and that it respects Ukraine’s independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity.

But later during a vote-out of United Nations Security Council’s resolution that condemning Crimea’s referendum, China abstained instead of siding with Russia, its close ally during UNSC vote out.


Related topics

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

The events of 1989 are totally different, but nevertheless the West antagonized China and Russia (compared to relatively recent crises like the 1980-90s massacre of Sikhs in Khalistan by India which did not cause the West to flinch). The West was slower to act and less restrictive on Russia despite Russia's military intervention in the Ukraine. France did not halt its Mistral assault ship sales (which could be deployed in the Black Sea) and the U.S. did stop space collaboration with Russia; suspending U.S. credit card operations in Russia started a new Russian industry; halting a Russo-Bombardier plane venture stalled sales. Pretty much nothing was done to prevent Crimea's impending absorption from the Ukraine.
oh boy....here we go.........."similar to the situation facing China after the 1989 crisis." However, what might be called the 1991 crisis of the Soviet Union is what the current Russia is politically based on, yet the Soviet Union has since collapsed. Thus their experience is based on the similarities of a hollowed out authoritarian dictatorship that has since collapsed and no longer exists - which I may add is the the base model for the Chinese Communist Party, which somehow, survived until the present. This is good for China as they need new working models. The Party can learn a lot from this. Nonetheless, one can be sure, readers in China cannot read about the Tiananmen "crisis" from the Russian embassy web site. Most young people in China today have no idea that something even happened on that date.


SCMP.com Account