• Fri
  • Dec 19, 2014
  • Updated: 4:56pm

Economist story on 'bumbler' Ma causes storm in Taiwan

PUBLISHED : Monday, 19 November, 2012, 12:00am
UPDATED : Monday, 19 November, 2012, 4:30am

An article in British magazine The Economist branding Taiwan President Ma Ying-jeou "a bumbler" has set off a media storm on the island, causing even the opposition to give a rare show of support for him.

The report, published in the weekly's November 17 edition, detailed Taiwan's economic woes, ranging from stagnant salaries to a pension system threatened by bankruptcy, stating the island seemed to agree Ma was "an ineffectual bumbler".

"How can a 'bumbler' get a doctorate from Harvard?" said Wang Chien-shien, president of the Control Yuan, a branch of Taiwan's government in charge of monitoring the others, according to the Taipei-based daily China Times Sunday.

Ma, who received his doctorate in juridical sciences at Harvard in the early 1980s, was the target of a "biased" report, Finance Minister Chang Sheng-ford was quoted as saying by the Central News Agency.

Diplomatically isolated Taiwan is highly conscious of its image abroad, with the local press often reporting at length if the island is mentioned in international media, even if it is as part of the weather forecast.

The Economist's characterisation of Ma was a top news item in major Taiwanese papers on Sunday and a hot topic on the talk show circuit over the weekend.

Even the main opposition Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) came out in a rare show of support. "At this time, the entire nation, including the DPP, should work together to help the government," DPP chairman Su Tseng-chang was quoted as saying by The China Post newspaper.

Su linked this remark to his party's wish for a national conference aimed at addressing the island's economic problems.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

how can a bumbler get a PhD from Harvard, or for that matter any university?
OMG, you're joking right? More than 30% of ALL PhD's are bumblers.....
I am British, live in China, have my own factory here. I read the Economist regularly and I am always frustrated at their bias. I have been in China 7 years and know the country as well as any foreigner that reads news for hours per day and has a Chinese wife. I am often left dumbfounded at their inaccuracies in relation to their assessment of the Chinese economy. I include in this criticism the BBC - who frankly are worse. The BBC's reporters are China bashers extraordinaire. It would be an idiot that thought that China was perfect, but to get fundamental facts wrong is inexcusable. Dear BBC: Guangdong is NOT a provincial capital.
Maybe you are just not looking deep enough. Watching things "go by" in China probably gives you a distorted picture of the true reality….as if Chinese banks were really banks in the traditional sense…….


SCMP.com Account