• Sun
  • Sep 21, 2014
  • Updated: 10:20am


The world’s biggest telecom equipment maker, Huawei Technologies Co was sued by Cisco Systems in 2003 for allegedly infringing on its patents. In the US, security officials have accused it of allowing unauthorized access by the Chinese People's Liberation Army through its equipment. US political opposition forced Huawei to withdraw its purchase of 3Leaf systems in 2010.


Ex-CIA chief Hayden claims Huawei spies for Chinese state

PUBLISHED : Friday, 19 July, 2013, 11:35am
UPDATED : Saturday, 20 July, 2013, 2:24am

Michael Hayden, the former head of the CIA and National Security Agency, said yesterday it "goes without saying" that Chinese telecoms giant Huawei spies for Beijing.

Huawei, however, strongly denied Hayden's allegations.

Speaking to the Australian Financial Review, Hayden claimed China was engaged in unrestricted espionage against the West and said it was his belief that Huawei would have shared information with state agencies.

Huawei meets the communication needs of more than a third of the planet and our customers have the right to know what these unsubstantiated concerns are

Asked whether Huawei represented an unambiguous national security threat to the US and Australia, Hayden replied: "Yes, I believe it does."

Britain, the US and Australia have all raised concerns that Huawei's alleged ties to the Chinese state could see their telecoms infrastructure used for spying and cyberattacks.

Huawei's global cybersecurity officer John Suffolk, who has previously described the company as the "piggy in the middle" of the broader dispute over hacking between China and the United States, reportedly dismissed Hayden's comments. as tired, unsubstantiated and defamatory.

"It's time to put up or shut up," said Suffolk. Huawei's global cyber security officer, told the newspaper.

He described the comments made by Hayden as "tired, unsubstantiated defamatory remarks" and challenged him and other critics to present any evidence publicly.

"Huawei meets the communication needs of more than a third of the planet and our customers have the right to know what these unsubstantiated concerns are," Suffolk said.

The US Congress last year called for its exclusion from US government contracts. It was also barred from bidding for contracts to build Australia's national broadband network.

Hayden, a retired general, said he believed Western intelligence networks had hard evidence that Huawei had spied on behalf of the Chinese state.

"I have no reason to question the belief that's the case," said Hayden, who retired from the CIA in 2009 and who prior to that served as head of the National Security Agency (NSA).

"That's my professional judgment. But as the former director of the NSA, I cannot comment on specific instances of espionage or any operational matters.

"At a minimum, Huawei would have shared with the Chinese state intimate and extensive knowledge of the foreign telecommunications systems it is involved with. I think that goes without saying."

Hayden said Huawei had approached him several years ago to be on the firm's American board, but failed to convince him it should be involved in critical communications infrastructure.

"This is not blind prejudice on my part. This was my considered view based on a four-decade career as an intelligence officer," he said.

"My conclusion was that it is simply not acceptable for Huawei to be creating the backbone of the domestic telecommunications network in the US."

Hayden is a director of Motorola Solutions, which provides radios, smart tags, barcode scanners and safety products. Huawei and Motorola Solutions had previously been engaged in intellectual property disputes for a number of years.

Hayden's remarks came a day after Britain announced it would review security at a cyber centre in England run by Huawei to ensure the British telecommunications network is protected.

The British government asked its National Security Adviser Kim Darroch to review the workings of a Huawei facility known as "the Cell".

Huawei, the world's second-largest maker of equipment for phone networks after Ericsson, was founded by Ren Zhengfei in 1987 after retiring from the Chinese military in 1983.

Additional reporting by Associated Press


Related topics

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

All that spying is to gain knowledge to cover their dirty landry and profit their greedy friends in power and silence anyone who threatens the status quo.
Michael Hayden walks and talks like a moron: "he believed Western intelligence networks had hard evidence....I have no reason to question the belief." Which is it? Hard evidence or belief?
Imperialist racism against the yellow horde requires no logic. Decades ago, Dean Rusk warned about a billion Chinese armed with nuclear weapons. The same fear persists to this day.
It's now documented companies like Google, Verizon, AT&T and many others fulfill NSA and CIA requests for unlimited information from their transactional databases. The US has now established a separate kangaroo court bypassing federal judicial system in processing ad hoc snooping permits on its own citizens.
Hong Kongers please take note. To a large extent, independent judiciary in Western countries is a myth. Majority of the judges in the US are elected. It goes without saying that jurists appointed by the president and state governors must also have similar political persuasion as their political masters, who in turn become electable only when they satisfy the requirements of powerful vested interests. This is the true meaning of balance of powers.
Election is a façade of power sharing to delude the powerless mass, who entertain the illusion of hiring and firing those who govern. A question for brainwashed folks: Does Democracy, whatever it is taken to mean, satisfy objective criteria for good governance? Superstition always preempts evidence.
As to Huawei spying for China, my response is 惡人先告狀.
Shameful. But it is quite amusing the way in which the American 'Intelligence' services are squirming post Snowden. (The word 'Intelligence' used with great irony.)
Team America Quote comes to mind:
Spottswoode: From what I.N.T.E.L.L.I.G.N.C.E has gathered, it would be 9/11 times 100.
Gary Johnston: 9/11 times a hundred? Jesus, that's...
Spottswoode: Yes, 91,100.
More likely the techies in US that do all the spying worry that huwai will encrypt data between their end points and they won't be able to monitor the Emails.
It goes without saying that any device created by Cisco has a Cisco provided back door for US government to connect into.
Please provide concrete evidence to back up your allegations, Mr. Hayden. For an example of concrete evidence, please refer to what Mr. Snowden provided for the world to see in terms of what and how the US spies on China, Hong Kong, and the rest of the world.
By the way, a few IP addresses traced to a building in Pudong doesn't mean ****.
Hmmm... Spy Vs Spy , its time for Hollywood to make movie...
This Hayden is basing everything on his own beliefs. Thats fine. We have reasons to believe he is an idiot.
Hayden conveniently left out Cisco, Google, Microsoft, Yahoo, Verizon, AT&T, all spy for US. they even put "secret rooms" in tech companies tapping the data before customers. one reason Hayden prefers local government uses US OEMs as all OEM has built in spying device monitoring american.
This has been known for years. He is not exactly telling news.




SCMP.com Account