• Tue
  • Jul 22, 2014
  • Updated: 8:14pm

Beijing holds fire after Shinzo Abe's controversial visit to war shrine

For now, China may only condemn Japanese PM and step up patrols around disputed islands

PUBLISHED : Saturday, 28 December, 2013, 2:58am
UPDATED : Saturday, 28 December, 2013, 4:15am

Beijing will refrain from taking any concrete response to Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's visit to a controversial war shrine as the central government assesses the impact on Tokyo's relationship with its neighbours and Washington.

Buoyed by the US government's strong criticism of Abe's visit, President Xi Jinping's administration is unlikely to do much more than condemn the move and step up patrols around the Diaoyu Islands, or Senkaku Islands as Japan calls them, which are claimed by both China and Japan.

The US embassy in Tokyo on Thursday expressed "disappointment" over the trip to the Yasukuni Shrine, which honours 2.5 million Japanese war dead, including 14 top-level war criminals. It said the visit would "exacerbate tensions".

Zhang Baohui , a security specialist at Lingnan University, said that while the alliance between Washington and Tokyo would probably remain strong, China would attempt to exploit any divisions between the two.

"China will not appear to be provocative so as to avoid forcing the US into giving strong backing to Tokyo," he said.

Japan's Jiji Press quoted a Japanese government source as saying that the US "worked again and again behind the scenes" to block the shrine visit.

"Washington is more cautious towards Abe because he seems to be getting out of control," said Jia Qingguo , an international relations specialist at Peking University.

Chinese state media continued to attack Abe. A commentary on the website of the People's Daily, the Communist Party's mouthpiece, said Beijing should recall its ambassador to Tokyo. An editorial in the Global Times, which is published under the People's Daily, called on Beijing to put Abe administration officials on a "most unwelcome" list.

But the Foreign Ministry stopped short of threatening direct action. "I will not respond to commentaries in the media," ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said. "But I believe all of us can see that the behaviour of Japanese leaders have ignited protest and anger from Chinese people."

Chinese-language media outlets based in Japan have speculated that Abe may have decided to visit the shrine after his requests to visit Beijing and Seoul were turned down last week. A spokesman for the Chinese embassy in Tokyo said yesterday the time was "not suitable" to talk about any Abe visit.

In a sign that Beijing was refraining from any provocative moves, mainland activists supporting Chinese sovereignty over the Diaoyus said authorities had barred them from protesting.

"We planned to give petition letters to the Japanese embassy in Beijing and consulate in Shanghai," said Li Yiqiang , an executive member of the China Federation for Defending the Diaoyu Islands. "But we were blocked by police on the way."

Meanwhile, a lawsuit brought against Japanese authorities by two Diaoyus activists from Hong Kong was rejected by the Supreme People's Court. Campaigners Lo Chau and Chan Miu-tak flew to Beijing on Thursday to sue the Japanese coastguard and Okinawan authorities for 165 million yuan (HK$209 million) for "mental anguish" and damage to Lo's boat during their arrest for landing on the disputed islands in August last year. They were told they must first petition lower-level courts.

The island dispute highlights the difficult diplomatic issues facing the Obama administration in its "pivot" towards the Asia-Pacific region.

Sun Zhe , professor of international relations at Tsinghua University, said the US would not be too critical of Abe because it still needed Japan to offset China's growing influence in the region.

Business analysts are watching whether the shrine dispute will cause more setbacks to Japanese businesses in China.

Olive Xia, an analyst with brokerage firm Core Pacific-Yamaichi International, said Japanese carmakers' share of the China market would likely probably drop one to two percentage points to about 19 per cent. "We see limited impact as the anti-Japan sentiment is less serious than that caused by the territorial dispute," Xia said.

Additional reporting by Laura Zhou, Lo Wei and Samuel Chan



For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Chanaa ( 28th 11:02am)
so telling a live demonstration of a pathetic double act
so typical of so many physical and intellectual diaspora here
Dyslexic copycats who seek false comfort in
variations on the theme of Ah Q’s misperceived need to catch fleas
and biting hands that supply their needs
But realities of my words and thoughts are out of their depth
As inept ingrates ignorantly ape they unwittingly disintegrate
internal consumption starting from their back ends
they alone aren’t aware of the stinks
"EVERY country's politics has its ..."
big mouth full of rubbish
But why this subject is endless... again and again!!
Perhaps you should tell dat to Abe...
Beijing is "holding its fire" because they are politically bankrupt. The CCP is running out of cards to play, the only ones they hold are the "economy" card, & the "anti-Japan" card. Both of which they've been paying since Deng Xiao Ping's era, and both of which are running out. The World is sick and tired of Communist China acting like a victimized brat, when all along, it was the Communist Party that caused all their modern turmoils.
not all Chinese are CCP members u ****!!! we Chinese hate those **** dogs too!!!
where did I say that all Chinese are CCP members? The greatest enemy of Chinese people has always been the Communist Party. And please be more mature with your posts, thank you
this is chinese opera. Every country's politics has its domestic audience strategy seperate from international. The chinese govt plays Japan & US as its bogeyman. Similarly, to some idiot congressman in US, China is lucifer hell bent on US destruction both military & economically - takng over USSR's role after the 90s.
see thru this and the world is good again
"China is lucifer hell bent on US destruction both military & economically ."
Gosh, where do you see that? Any Chinese soldiers overseas doing what US soldiers did/do in Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq etc?
i think u need to read that line in full merc2233 before replying.
For over 50 years since 1950, China never complained about Yasukuni Shrine visits. Every Prime Minister has visited there, and they weren't for nationalistic reasons. PMs back then in fact could not have won on nationalistic political campaigns. So why in the last 10 years? The shrine has not changed. All recent "modifications" to the shrine to avoid war responsibility have been done in the last 7 years, only when China started complaining, which led to Korea complaining. You would think this is an issue decades old, it's not. The leaders in PRC are looking for ways for the public to vent the anger, anywhere but their own government. Don't be misled.
The Japanese did horrible things during WW2 just like the Germans, Italians and in fact everyone else. War is hell. Germans tried to commit genocide against the Jews, but do you see Israel complaining of "hurt feelings" against the German chancellor? Grow up China. Your time is limited if you don't solve your own civil unrest.
China was established in 1949. You think it has nothing else to do in the next 50 years than to protest against the shrine visits?
Germany decently did not commemorate its dead soldiers. If it did, the world, Europe and the Jews in particular, would condemn it just as China and Korea are condemning the Japanese shrine visit.
China had not celebrated the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Grow up before you make another statement.
apparently you are confused and somehow disillusioned and have all your facts wrong. But rest assure I will correct them for you.
Emp. Hirohito stopped going after those 14 Class A war criminals were included and his successor has never visited. You have to wonder why ? that was like 1978.
china and korea protested when news broke out during japan premier nakasone visit and realizing his mistake, he vowed never to visit ys. Again, you have to wonder why ? that was like 1985.
China, korea and other countries only knew about the YS inclusion on those 14 criminals in 1985. prior to that, nobody actually give a beep about ys.
do your own calculation ? It’s really simple and not as you stated like over 50 years..blah blah blah.
lessons of war is horrible ...does not matter who is right or wrong...and by this judgment, it is even more important to learn and accept history to prevent future wars by the next generation.
Japan said it has apologized not once but a hell lot of times ..but after every apology, Japanese gov still continue to deny its atrocities which I find really disturbing, insulting and arrogant.
and do not compare germans with Japanese ( I find this insulting as well ) ....germany and Europe have move on and all is forgiven...you have to wonder why other countries still harbor resentment with japan.
go figure out before you make stupid remarks.
Since you have such easily "hurt feelings" on a news source that's clearly spewing PRC propaganda, you must like coming here a lot.
You think China is doing it's people a favour by calling for hostilities against the Japanese? In 20 years, cancers and respiratory ailments will have killed off huge percentages of the population, leading to further civil unrest as medical costs soar. And most of these funds will go to American and EU medical companies because Chinese pharmaceuticals can't be trusted. See dead children last week from Hep B vaccine.
I look forward to do the day that the PRC government has self-destructed, children are taught about Tiannamen, the 30m+ killed under Mao and the billions of RMB smuggled out by so-called party members.
You want to be angry at the Japanese? You should be angry at the CPCC. They are the ones making China worse, day by day. The next 5 year plan will do little to reduce unsustainable urbanization, air pollution, quality of health, medical care and social services. Combined with a huge shadow debt-laden economy, shouting and waging war against Japan is a distraction from all I have listed above. You better look deeper than the xenophobic hatred your beloved CPCC leaders are hoping you swallow. Don't be so naive.
don't change the subject....this is about idiot abe provocation by visiting ys.
just say and admit he is an idiot and we move on...
you don't have to be born raise in china but even a blind bat can see right and wrong...remorse and fake apology....deceit and sincerity...from abe.
I don't have a problem with Japanese ppl but we will not accept or take any bulls**t from japan govt that continue to glorified their past and deny the truth ! china is right !
ok so we Chinese hate CCP and JPs dogs alike!!! what's the problem u JP c***sucker?

It is easy for China to strike out Yasukuni with MIRV and/or cruise missiles
to once and for all finally finish off WWII
In recognition of that Akihito pleaded for peace in his latest speech
Abe the serial provocateur overwhelmed by fears
has been demonstrating his paranoia
A funny and shameful nation with an insular mentality
may never learn to appreciate the magnanimousness of a great nation
like CHINA
insular mentality, serial provocateur overwhelmed with fears, paranoia.
are you describing yourself pslhk ? sure sounds like it
No, fool, launching a nuclear missile at Japan will start a new war from which China will suffer terribly. That is a foolish idea but you Chinese fools just don't see it. Too blinded by your imagined military prowess to see. The enemy this time would not be unarmed Tibetan monks and nuns, but guys with real guns who are capable of fighting back. The last peradventure that China made to Vietnam ended up with the vaunted PLA coming back with its tail between its legs.
Send in the Cheng Guan!! The only true fighters in China!!
The refusal to bury old grievances almost inevitably leads to future war. Is that what the Chinese and Korean leaders want? Responsible leaders would lodge their routine objections to Yasukuni Shrine visits by Japanese politicians and leave it at that.
The overheated rhetoric followed by inaction shows that the Chinese & Korean leaders are whingeing pussies who love to wallow in their countries' historical victimhood but when it comes to action they are contemptuous paper tigers who deserve no respect.
old grievances should be settled, preferably by peaceful means. Just like debt, it should either be forgiven or repaid. It is unreasonable to expect the Chinese and the Korean to bury their grievances as if nothing has happened.
You said inaction. What action do you expect that would be justified under the circumstances ? Is Japan asking for a war, or the first shot ? I am sure China will be a lot wiser as to fall into any Japanese trap. Any action that China and Korea will take will still be peaceful in nature, but it will also be perfectly understood that China is able and willing to defend itself from any attack by Japan. As Kennedy said once, civility is not a sign of weakness, it is a sign of strength.
This was most probably a highly calculated move by Abe. He thought China can do nothing to stop him, and not much more to retaliate after the ADIZ. It is a **** for tat for Japan. However it is not true that China has no more card in its sleeve. Japan has just given China a most valuable chance to destroy Japan's credibility on the case itself.
Since everything revolves around the dispute, China will go back to the origin of the dispute once more, with more emphasis on WW2 and the post war order.
This will be a new propaganda war against Japan, over the results of WW2, that Japan is so far unable and unwilling to recognize. This will put the lime light back on "history" where Japan is so weak in its defense of the case, in which China has clearly a far more convincing case. The shrine visit has proved that Japan's right wing government has largely ignored the historic implications of the second world war, and that China is right.
I believe the best thing for the chinese to do is to have our leader, Xi Jinping, pay a visit to the Memorial Hall to the victims of the Nanjing Massacre with a whole host of political leaders. We need to bring attention to the world as to how savage and vicious Japan has been in the past and that there is potential for that country to return to it's warring roots. This is a moment where we chinese can illustrate to the world that we abhor war and bring attention to Japanese attrocities committed upon the Chinese and Koreans before and during the WWII. That would be a fantastic rebuttal to the bonehead Shinzo Abe for visiting the Yasukuni shrine. Abe needs to understand that you can't pick and choose your country's history, you either embrace all of it or none of it. The fact will always remain in history books how Japan brutalized their neighbor. The best thing of the whole debacle, is that should tensions ratchet up in the region, Japan has left the United States an excuse not to back them up, for Japan unilaterally decided to inflame the anger of the people of China and Korea, for there are still individuals living that remember the period when the Japanese occupied China.
As the Jewish people has not let the world forget the atrocities of German concentration camps, we Chinese should start to educate the world in how the Japanese brutalized the Chinese during WWII. For if we forget the past, we are doomed to re-live it.
Then he can go back to worshipping the man responsible for more deaths in China than anyone else in recent memory, the Great Helmsman, whom they adore and idolize, Xi's minor comments notwithstanding. I guess that if you kill 20-30 million of your own people it is not as bad.
Let's not confuse the issues. What is your view on the visit to the shrine?
If you smack your own kid, it's OK. If someone else smacks your kid...it's not.
Of course that's so.
@ tat.wong.7923
spot on ...brilliant actually I must say...and lets just ignore that ignorant soon to be worship @ ejmcii @ YS.


SCMP.com Account