• Thu
  • Dec 18, 2014
  • Updated: 2:01pm

War of words erupts as John Kerry calls Beijing 'provocative' in South China Sea disputes

Foreign minister hits back after John Kerry calls Chinese actions in South China Sea 'provocative'

PUBLISHED : Tuesday, 13 May, 2014, 5:09pm
UPDATED : Wednesday, 14 May, 2014, 6:04pm

China and the United States exchanged heated words yesterday over the recent tensions between Beijing and its neighbours about disputed territory in the South China Sea.

"[John Kerry] said China's introduction of an oil rig and numerous government vessels in waters disputed with Vietnam was provocative," US State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said, referring to a telephone call between the US secretary of state and Foreign Minister Wang Yi .

Wang called on the US to be objective and urged it to "stick to its promises, and act and speak cautiously", according to a statement on the Foreign Ministry's website.

Ministry spokesman Hua Chunying said China had not taken any provocative moves in the South China Sea.

"The US' mistaken comments have encouraged dangerous and provocative actions," she said in a daily press briefing. "We expect the US to reflect on its acts. If it expects the Pacific Ocean to be peaceful, it should think what role it can play in maintaining regional peace and stability."

The exchange between the two top diplomats came as tensions between China and Vietnam escalated after Beijing positioned an oil rig on May 1 in the Paracel Islands - called the Xisha Islands by China and the Hoang Sa Islands in Vietnam, which also claims them.

The US can showcase the importance of its presence in the Asia Pacific
Professor Wang Fan

At the same time, the Philippines decided to prosecute nine of 11 Chinese fishermen apprehended in the disputed Spratly Islands for poaching sea turtles. Manila said it released two fishermen because they were minors.

"We were told that the two minors would be released soon," said Dai Yudao, an official of an association that represents the fishermen in Qionghai, Hainan province.

"But we are not familiar with the Philippine legal system and don't know what will happen to the other fishermen."

Beijing and Hanoi have been engaged in a stand-off over the past week, with both accusing each other of ramming ships.

In signs that the tensions may linger for some time, several thousand Vietnamese workers protested at an industrial park in Binh Duong province in southern Vietnam yesterday over Beijing's deployment of the oil rig. The plant is Taiwanese-owned and makes footwear. The workers waved banners and shouted anti-China slogans, Vietnam's Thanh Nien Daily reported on its website.

Employees of other production plants also joined the protest.

About 1,000 workers from Mega Step Electronics, which is under the Hong Kong-based Fittec International Group, also took part, Thanh Nien said.

In a meeting with Singapore's foreign minister, K. Shanmugam, yesterday, Kerry said the US was concerned about the Chinese challenge to the Paracel Islands.

"We want to see a code of conduct created; we want to see this resolved peacefully through the Law of the Sea, through arbitration, through any other means, but not direct confrontation and aggressive action," he said.

Wang Fan, a professor at the China Foreign Affairs University, said the conversation between the Chinese and American top diplomats indicated that both nations were taking steps to avoid the territorial disputes becoming another flashpoint between Beijing and Washington.

"On one hand, the US can showcase the importance of its presence in the Asia Pacific, and draw Southeast Asian nations closer to Washington with the disputes between Beijing and its neighbours," he said. "But on the other hand, it does not want the dispute to get out of control."

Additional reporting by Agence France-Presse, Reuters


More on this story

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

M Miyagi
US Secretary of State Dracula looking John Kerry after sucking blood in Ukraine is now sucking blood in Asia. Shameless. The buggers in Hanoi should know better as the US at the first opportunity would use their agents in the South to overthrow them. If the Hanoi government got any intelligence they should be using this opportunity to flush out the US agents in Vietnam and kill them all!
John Kerry is absolutely correct. Finally, call it what it is. China thinks that everything that touches water is theirs and are willing to bully smaller countries to get everything it wants. I'm not big fan of the US, but enough is enough.
Gulf of Tonkin incident August 1964...I trust the Chinese are more intelligent than the U.S. were then
Jonathan Smith
John Kerry is a hypocrite.
How About
Yes Miyagi, you can almost see how SOS Kerry + Veep Biden choking green- they went to bark at Ukraine and Kiev and see what they now created- another torn-up principality and or civil-war in the making. And this is exactly what they'll end up doing here too. Speaking of long memory they simply cannot let go it was Vietnam who kicked their a s s so they love to manipulate Vietnam to stir trouble with China for a payback.
I Gandhi
And the US is not provocative in Asia?
USA continually interferes with other nations that do not appear to serve its own purpose but the interference is inconsistent as none in Syria. Now Kerry, Biden, so-called "war hero" McLain all in the same bag of trouble-making and persistent China-bashing where there should be peaceful dialogue and cooperation.
美國在中國南海煽風點火鼓勵騷亂 鼓勵越南和菲律賓攻擊中國人造成生命和財產損失 United States fanning the flames at South China Seas encourage riots in Vietnam and Philippines costing Chinese lives and Chinese owned property damages there
Couldn't the US simply stick to its own territorial waters. After all the US is only making these pronouncements based on its own ability to make military threats. If China now happens to be stronger than Vietnam in a disputed area, then bad luck Vietnam. Much of the world's map and boundaries have been drawn up based on who beat who in the past. There were no gentlemen's agreements. So now the Paracels belong to China not based on any rights or wrongs, but simply because they are the top dogs in the region. Take a hike Kerry.
does anyone in the real world still listen to what the USA has to say about anything? can the scmp stop doing news on what obama and his team say.



SCMP.com Account