NewsHong Kong
HEALTH SERVICES

Union Hospital, Tai Wai, boosts birth fee to deter mainland mothers

Private hospital increases maternity charge to up to HK$270,000 for mainland women without HK husbands using its emergency ward

Friday, 09 November, 2012, 7:24am

Poll

  • Yes: 69%
  • No: 31%
9 Nov 2012
  • Yes
  • No

A private hospital is almost tripling its maternity fee to up to HK$270,000 to deter mainland women without Hong Kong husbands from giving birth at the last minute in its emergency ward.

The move is among several to be introduced next year at Union Hospital in Tai Wai, which has the city's only private emergency facilities.

The measures are aimed only at mainland women who fall under the government's "zero quota" policy for such births.

Mainland women who have Hong Kong husbands will not be affected.

Deputy medical director Dr Ares Leung Kwok-ling said the hospital also wanted to forestall any moves by unscrupulous mainland agencies to arrange "gatecrashing" births, a common ploy at emergency wards.

"There are rumours that some middleman agencies are arranging for mainland women to use illegal methods to overstay in the city and rush into emergency wards for last-minute deliveries," Leung said.

"Our emergency ward may be not able to refuse gatecrashing cases for humane reasons, but we hope that these measures … should be able to stop them from using this method."

In addition to the usual maternity fee of HK$80,000 to HK$100,000 charged to local women, the hospital will charge mainland women without a local husband between HK$150,000 and HK$170,000 for using the emergency unit.

The hospital will also report the women, who have usually entered the city illegally or overstayed their visa, to the police and related authorities, leaving them liable to prosecution.

"We believe the police will also trace and prosecute the intermediaries for aiding and abetting the women or providing accommodation during the overstay period," Leung said.

Such women will also be allowed to see only the duty doctors, not those of their choice, to prevent any collusion between doctors and agencies - although no such case has yet been uncovered at the hospital. The "zero quota" policy, announced by Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying in April bans all mainland woman without a Hong Kong husband from booking maternity beds from next year. Leung also warned that their babies may not gain the Hong Kong permanent residence that is a key attraction for mainland parents.

Union Hospital, where mainland mothers once made up 60 per cent of the maternity cases, expects the ban to decrease the use of its maternity services.

Bookings are already down 40 per cent for the first quarter of next year from the same period this year.

The number of mainland women gatecrashing public emergency units has dropped significantly from a monthly average of 150 cases at the end of last year to 25 last month.

3

This article is now closed to comments

USA_IS_BEST
This really shows the humanitarian side of these doctors, who obviously value money over helping people. Terrible place.
Kevin Lau
It is a good news for HK mothers. The government and hospitals have been devising measures to address the mainland mother issue. Although the charge of birth is increased to $150000 and $170000, it is not an effective resort to deter the mainland mothers. It is due to once their children are granted the permanent residency, their children can earn back what they paid through claiming the public resource of HK.
shafinhk
It sounds lovely to see the amount $170,000, as an additional fine or charges for giving birth a baby without an appointment by a mainland mother. But in Practically what Hong Kongers can do when a mother will not have money to pay? Bankruptcy? sound funny...as she may be penniless and you will end up paying legal cost for such action.
Hong Kong government should built a mechanism to control this. Such as makeing a mandatory mother study course for mothers for giving birth in Hong Kong. Mainland mothers will not have visa to study and therefore will not be able to study and give birth. And those who will jump or by pass the system, they should not be given back their children and instead should be given in the custody of the Social welfare department unless until they can provide a certificate of that mandatory study. they will never be able to study and will never be able to take back their child.
Do it with one, rest will be STOPPED for rest of life.
this method will also help Hong Kong mothers to have better relationship with their kids.

Login

SCMP.com Account

or