NewsHong Kong
INTEGRATION

Hong Kong losing its advantage as China's 'go-between' with world: Report

Conflict inevitable as mainland market becomes more internationalised and less reliant on the city as an intermediary, trade report reveals

Tuesday, 06 November, 2012, 11:41am

Hong Kong's advantage as an intermediary between the mainland and the outside world is on the wane, and it is natural for conflicts to emerge between the city and the mainland, says a report compiled by several central government agencies.

These problems will surface as the pace of economic and trade development between the city and the mainland slows, the report on economic and trade co-operation between Hong Kong and mainland China, said.

The paper, published yesterday, was compiled by the State Information Centre, the Hong Kong branches of Xinhua and People's Daily, and Hong Kong-based China Institute of Culture.

Speaking at a seminar on the launch of the report, Dr Fang Zhou, assistant chief research officer at Hong Kong's One Country Two Systems Research Institute, said that to deal with the conflict, the SAR government must improve its economic planning and clarify the city's orientation as China moves forward.

Referring to late US president John Kennedy's famous quote, Fang said: "Hong Kong should not just ask what the country can do for you, ask instead what Hong Kong can do for China."

He was responding to a view in the report that "as Hong Kong and the mainland further integrate in economic and social aspects, some problems and conflicts that were less obvious before will gradually emerge, especially those deep-rooted problems implied in the '[one country,] two systems' concept".

The paper noted that the mainland's direct investment in the city had dropped 8 per cent, from a record US$38.6 billion in 2008 to US$35.7 billion last year.

It said Hong Kong and mainland China must assess the situation "objectively and calmly".

"They must not blame each other, nor be discouraged, nor anxious … and they must definitely not turn to a road of retrogression," the paper said.

While the mainland market was quickly opening and becoming more internationalised thus causing Hong Kong's advantage as an intermediary to wane, the report said, Hong Kong would still keep its other advantages for the long term.

"Hong Kong's core competitive advantages" such as its free market, independent judiciary, graft-free administration and internationalised society "could further stand out," it said.

Meanwhile, Zhang Huiguang, representative of the State-owned Cultural Assets Supervision and Administration Office in Beijing, said the office was willing to "use every channel" to boost co-operation between Hong Kong and Beijing in cultural and creative development.

Speaking at a forum in Hong Kong, she said the two cities had their own advantages.

Hong Kong companies could use Beijing to enter the cultural and creative industries in the mainland, while Beijing could use Hong Kong to spread their influence in the international market.

Zhang, who is also head of the Beijing Tourism Administration, said she had noticed that more Beijing people were visiting Hong Kong after the relaxation of permit rules in September.

Until September 1, Beijing's non-permanent residents had to return to their hometowns to get a permit to visit Hong Kong.

11

This article is now closed to comments

deandean
Too many Hong Kongers know neither their own reality of what's actually happening in the mainland (of which they're too scared of). I am never surprised when I see another big multinational franchise in Shenzhen but NOT in Hong Kong.
Australia for example just released a white paper on learning Asian Languages. Putonghua was on the list... hey... even Indonesian and Hindi... not Cantonese. After the report that Hong Kong's English is falling behind South Korea and Japan, how useful is Hong Kong as a middle-man between the West and China?
andreaswagner
As long as Hong Kong has the rule of law, and it's superior infrastructure, its place as a competitive international city will always be guaranteed. These are the qualities that set Hong Kong apart, and which mainland China can't buy with all the money it has.
Oh, who made the report again? Ah, I see :)
SpeakFreely
HK people are too complacent in fact we are not competitive at all...our cost is too high being competitive n too much relying on china. Forget about those ranking form WEF etc is all nonsense...just made us feel complacent. Period.
dylanho
There is never any need to rely on anyone. Reliance is always a negative form of relationship to begin with and often leads to doom. HK should find the spirit to develop its potential seeing itself as an independent entity and see leverages on any relationships with Mainland as an additional form of bonus. Self-reliance creates strength. With the right mental strength and being sufficiently flexible minded, there is nothing that HK cannot achieve.
jpinst
Well, if a Central Government Agency issued the report, it must be true……
tobychun
"Hong Kong's core competitive advantages" such as its free market, independent judiciary, graft-free administration and internationalised society "could further stand out,"
Unfortunately those are the exact things that Beijing is trying to take away from HK... LOL.
Kevin Lau
Inevitably, HK will lose the role as a intermediary between China and the worlds. As the main cities of China have built up their own connections between China and the world, it is not necessary to assess the world through HK. HK government should be aware that HK can not rely on the role as intermediary to develop its economy any more. The government should diversify its economies intead of begging the advantages from China.
SpeakFreely
Well said but HK people are just too complacent with status quote. We will collapse one China can trade freely without HK...plus we have aging population n not so aggressive young generation very similar to Japan.
icwu
Hong Kong has been praised as one of the most free economy in the world with a sterling infrastructure for decades. And indeed it has worked. Unfortunately, this praise has been greatly exagerated and indeed Hong Kong has not lived up to expectation for years especially since the 'turnover'. In short, what Hong Kong needs to do is to vigorously enhance its core values, in which, Hong Kong needs particularly to do the following among others i.e. 1. to broaden, revamp and further lower its taxes and tax structure (McCain's 999 plan should be good for Hong Kong), 2. to further strenghten its legal structure, 3. to further broaden the representation in its political system. With these properly implemented, our advantages will be greatly increased and appreciated and will naturally attract talented people and trades to Hong Kong. We don't really need to beg for preferential treatments from the Central government. I think the Leung administration is barking up the wrong tree !
SpeakFreely
Hk over over rated. We are not a free economy at all. Government and developers use land to control our economy making it like a monopoly. Our costs of doing biz is too high. Our GDP has been flat. Our technology sucks and behind many countries. Our government is not small as a % of GDP. Not a free economy as said. Our Legco argue for nonsense much worst than US congress...

Pages

Login

SCMP.com Account

or