• Sat
  • Dec 27, 2014
  • Updated: 6:01am
Leung Chun-ying
NewsHong Kong

Leung Chun-ying refuses to bite over Stanley flat extensions

CY faces fresh questions over latest controversy but others are urging Hongkongers to move on

PUBLISHED : Sunday, 16 December, 2012, 12:00am
UPDATED : Sunday, 16 December, 2012, 8:45am

Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying yesterday refused to be drawn into talking at length about an unauthorised extension to a flat he owns in Stanley as he attended the annual Brands and Products Expo.

Leung tried to end the saga over illegal structures at his home on The Peak by apologising for his handling of the matter in the Legislative Council last week. Controversy began after Leung was elected in March, when the existence of unauthorised additions to the property, including a garden trellis, was revealed.

During election campaigning Leung had criticised his rival for the top job, Henry Tang Ying-yen, over the recent construction of a luxurious 2,300 sq ft basement at the Tang family home in Kowloon Tong.

On Friday, the Buildings Department confirmed that it had found illegal structures in 2001 at a flat in Stanley that Leung bought in 1979 and in which he and his family lived until 2000. The unauthorised works were being demolished at the time officials confirmed their existence, the department said.

This prompted new questions - about the size of the extension, what it was used for, and when and at whose instruction it was built. Some reports said the extension was 2,000 sq ft in area.

Speaking after the opening of the expo in Victoria Park, Causeway Bay, Leung said the flat had been restored to comply fully with the building plan.

"The department did not spot any problems" when officials checked the property, now let to tenants, last week, he added.

He would not go into details about the unauthorised works.

In its statement, the department said "illegal structures including a roof rail, column, wall, staircases and slabs" were found in a space between the flat in Tung Tau Wan Road and an artificial slope in 2001.

Executive Councillor Fanny Law Fan Chiu-fun said the matter had been settled more than 10 years ago, and called on Hongkongers to move on.

"I hope society can let bygones be bygones and spare the government time and space to work on more pressing issues," she said.

Leung will make his first duty visit to Beijing on Thursday. On the eve of his departure, the Labour Party will propose a resolution to invoke the Legislative Council's Powers and Privileges Ordinance to launch an inquiry over illegal structures at Leung's properties.

Labour Party chairman Lee Cheuk-yan said the controversy over the Stanley property had raised fresh questions about Leung's integrity. An inquiry could also look into whether government officials had shielded Leung, he said.

In a gesture to put the focus back on to livelihood issues, Leung and his wife, Regina Leung Tong Ching-yee, yesterday spent HK$1,200 at the expo on a handbag and handicrafts.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

hard times !
Though this old nasty guy C.Y.refused to bite over his Stanley flat extensions yet they really once existed after he bought the flat located at No.39 Tung Tau Wan Rd.,Stanley since 1979. And the suspected/geniune extensions is learnt to occupy an area of over 2000 sq.ft --similiar to the size of Henry Tang's Kowloon Tong basement palace.Though the illegal/unauthorized works had been demolished in 2001 when the Buildings Dept.staff checked the premises after learning about their existence in 2000.Anyway,this new discovery/disclosure proves that Leung is not a green hand in building illegal structures as he claimed after his Peak houses have been found to have 10 illegal strutures and he privately had a space (measuring about 320 sq.ft) sealed by a wall which is itself an illegal structure.This eloquent and sly old guy has proved by his acts and words that he just can't be trusted by most in town either in his words or deeds since his integrity is broke completely indeed !
so any tom **** n harry in HK are allowed to say their UBWs are bygones because its ok for the Chief Exec to say the same.. huh? how the hec is he gonna govern?
The Stanley circumstances are not "bygones"; they prove that Leung, on top of his own personal surveying knowledge and expertise, must have been keenly aware of the status of UBWs on his Peak property, ignored the law, tried to hide the facts by lying repeatedly, making up all manner of tall tales in the process.


SCMP.com Account