• Sat
  • Dec 27, 2014
  • Updated: 9:34am
NewsHong Kong

Veterinary surgeon shortage 'poses threat to public health'

'Shameful' shortage of care experts on farms due to city's lack of a training school may lead to rise in animal-related diseases, experts say

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 27 December, 2012, 12:00am
UPDATED : Thursday, 27 December, 2012, 7:07am

A severe shortage of veterinary surgeons in Hong Kong is hitting farmers and posing a threat to public health.

The crisis has been caused by a lack of veterinary training in the city and the fact that more than 90 per cent of the 400-plus vets practising in Hong Kong care for household pets.

The issue has emerged at a time when the World Health Organisation (WHO) is warning of a mounting threat to humans from animal-related diseases.

Veterinarian and infectious disease specialist Howard Wong Kai-hay said: "Hong Kong may be one of the few places in the world where we raise livestock and produce meat without [the supervision of] veterinarians.

"That is pretty shameful ... especially when we require meat from other countries to meet high standards."

Wong, who is City University's life science programmes director, said Hong Kong sat in a part of Asia where many diseases emerged and needed more animal care experts and academic research on the topic. "We are way behind time," he added.

And Dr Jane Gray, chief veterinary surgeon for the Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA), said: "There is definitely a lack of veterinary training in Hong Kong. The region is a hotbed for disease and more should be done about public health issues involving animals."

The WHO warned recently that 70 per cent of emerging diseases were animal-related.

Director-general Dr Margaret Chan Fung Fu-chun warned of a growing trend of deadly illnesses - such as Sars and bird flu - jumping from animals to humans.

With no veterinary school, local people wanting to pursue the career must train overseas and many stay to practise in the country of their qualifications.

Of 650 vets registered in the city, only about 400 practise here. This means there are just 68 veterinarians per 1 million population, compared to 281 in Japan and 332 in Australia.

Adding to the pressure is a growing trend for pet ownership with the numbers surging 40 per cent to 415,000 last year.

Agriculture and fisheries lawmaker Steven Ho Chun-yin said: "There are not enough vets in the city and most vets are keener to run private pet clinics than work on the farm."

Ho said most of the 70 local farms were without resident veterinarians for their average daily output of 255 pigs and 10,300 live chickens.

If there is an outbreak of disease, farmers have to alert the Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department (AFCD), which will send a veterinarian.

But Ho said a resident vet would be able to detect early symptoms that farmers might not identify.

City University, which wants to establish the city's first veterinary school in 2014 - including a training farm, hospital and laboratory - submitted a new proposal to the University Grants Committee on December 10. It will be considered in January.

Gray said while the SPCA had no trouble recruiting, it had difficulty retaining experienced staff.

The AFCD, which employs 25 vets, has five vacancies but says it has no recruiting problems.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Dear Editor,
Pls refer to the url below.
The 265 farms in 2006 quoted by AFCD have now dwindled to 70. Why was there no mention at all about this important fact? In fact, vets now have trouble looking for jobs worldwide in the current economic downturn!
"Ho said most of the 70 local farms were without resident veterinarians for their average daily output of 255 pigs and 10,300 live chickens."
A vet school costing billions to serve the 255 pigs and 10,300 live chickens? City U is talking rubbish, but SCMP deemed it fit for the front page lead....
BTW, can the reporter pls clarify where the pig and chicken farms are? The 255 and 10,300 average daily output figures are dubious at best, and alarming if true. I thought all chicken farms were eradicated since the deadly H5N1 outbreaks? Pig farms have almost ceased to exist too, right?
This is an absurd, unbalanced, poorly researched and over-blown main front page story, which has clearly been promoted by those with an agenda, which is to establish a veterinary school at City University. The final sentence states that the AFCD does not have a problem recruiting vets. Does that not tell you that the entire premise upon which the article was written is false?


SCMP.com Account