NewsHong Kong
CONSUMER AFFAIRS

Two-can limit on milk powder to stop cross-border traders

Cross-border market in baby formula leads to series of tough measures, with fines of up to HK$2 million and seven-year jail sentences

Saturday, 02 February, 2013, 12:00am

Poll

  • Yes: 30%
  • No: 70%
2 Feb 2013
  • Yes
  • No

People departing Hong Kong will be limited to taking two cans, or 1.8kg, of milk powder in the latest government effort to crack down on trading by mainlanders that has led to shortages in the city.

The change, imposed under a legislative amendment and expected to take effect as soon as this month, was among a basket of measures announced by the administration yesterday.

Those found guilty of breaking the new rule could be fined up to HK$2 million or face seven years in jail.

But critics said the amendment would take too long, while lawmakers and mothers - struggling to find milk formula for their children - said traders may still stockpile powder and make multiple trips across the border to sell it in Shenzhen at higher prices.

Announcing the plan yesterday, Secretary for Food and Health Dr Ko Wing-man said it would not cause parallel trading to "drop to zero" but could "greatly discourage parallel traders from making a big impact".

He said the change to the Import and Export Ordinance would require Executive Council approval and theoretically could be passed this month.

Other measures were announced to help combat shortages in the meantime.

A 24-hour government hotline was set up yesterday for parents to place orders for seven major formula brands.

And mainlanders who repeatedly travel across the border with bulky packages could be blacklisted by the Immigration Department, with their names passed to the Shenzhen authorities.

Also, the MTR will tighten the weight limit for passenger luggage from the current 32kg to 23kg from Monday. Many mothers said the action was better than nothing, but some, together with a pharmacy owner, said the two-can limit may be too loose.

"There are such a large number of traders and they can each travel many times to carry their stock," one mother wrote on the internet forum Baby Kingdom.

The Hong Kong Retail Management Association said it hoped the measure would not affect the city's image as a free market and a shoppers' paradise.

Democratic Party lawmaker Helena Wong Pik-wan and NeoDemocrats said the measures would not prevent parallel trading in other commodities.

The NeoDemocrats called for the abolition of the multiple-entry permit scheme for mainlanders that has fuelled the surge in parallel trading.

But Secretary for Security Lai Tung-kwok said this was not the way to solve the problem and might lead to "negative impacts".

Executive councillor Regina Ip Lau Suk-yee said the government could still consider making formula a "reserved commodity" like rice. But Ko said: "We think [the limit] is the best way to pinpoint the problem."

 

Steps officials will take to control parallel trading of infant formula

1 Amend Import and Export Ordinance to restrict number of tins of infant formula travellers can carry to two, or 1.8kg in total (done within this month)

2 A 24-hour government hotline for parents to order formula: 3142 2288 (from 6pm yesterday)

3 Lower the MTR's maximum weight limit for passenger luggage on the East Rail Line from the current 32kg to 23kg (starting Monday)

4 Monitor suspicious travellers who carry commodities in bulk and cross the border repeatedly every day, denying entry on a case by case basis

 

18

This article is now closed to comments

Renegade Barry
Children and mothers are suffering while waiting for legislation. Buy from somewhere else to increase milk stocks. Diversify the supply and people should have ID before they can be sold milk products to ensure that HK citizens will have ample supply and limit those who are just visiting.
maecheung
Data shows 60% of these smugglers have HKID card.
bobbylad15
Announcing a cap before you implement is terrible, it gives one month to smugglers to increase the amount they import before their supply is reduced. It could make the problem worse in the short term.
Also for these people who suggest setting up "distribution centres" and such near the border are totally missing the point. If China allowed duty free imports of baby formula then this whole crisis would not exist. The use of these terms like "parallel trader" instead of smuggler to address "sensitivities" is clouding the issue. These people are seeking to evade paying due taxes in mainland China by using Hong Kong and placing potentially the lives of some children in danger to do it. Making it easier for them to do their "business" would harm Hong Kong and China even more.
Anyway, a lot of people are missing a bigger point with all this. Breast feeding is a far better way to feed a baby!
mychiu
Two cans is still way too much! If the government can set a limit of 19 cigarettes to prevent cigarette parallel trading, then it should set the baby formula limit at 895 grams. That's 5 grams short of a can. People bringing a can of baby formula out will be required to open it and deposit on spoonful in a transparent waste box, the way you have to drop off your bottled water in airports before you access the departure lounge. If the formula is genuinely for personal consumption, then one spoonful less won't matter. Once opened, the can of formula cannot be resold. Kill the profit opportunity. Problem solved. Do to milk what you do to cigarettes! That's the reason the government won't allow you to bring in two packs of cigarettes.
Why allow two cans? Why are we protected the illegal and immoral profiteering of these people? After all, you can get the exact same product in China.
SpeakFreely
I guess Hk government need helps fromSZ officials but still need to take care of their interest ( off allowing certain degree of illegal activities) for someone to pay the bill...
SpeakFreely
Hk is still using very outdated technology and not using online ordering as parents are likely to repeat their order. I tested call the hotline and I was told I can put an order and a supplier will call in few days time to either arrange delivery or pick up. But she doesn't know whether there are charges for delivery or how long will it takes to deliver. hK need to outsource this to Amazon as you can track your order and easily submit your order. I say outsource I was jjust kidding but this shows how backward we are in technology here still relying on hotlines! Also I hope the suppliers can guarantee timing of the orders otherwise will be another hide and seek games. But in any case this is an improvement already that I suggested on day one.
johndoe
The 23 kg weight limit is stupid. On a normal airplane you can bring 20 kg checked plus 7 kg hand carry. If I am going to the airport with 27 kg of luggage, will I be stopped? Ridiculous!
jhk
"HK$2 million or face seven years in jail"
Then they really should switch to smuggling drugs instead. I'm sure the punishment would be lower.
johnfra
Punishment for human trafficking is even lower.
johnfra
This is good for a laugh if it is not such a sad episode.
You remember there was a time when Europe was pouring away milk because prices have plummeted. How stupid they look now. If only they can turn it into powder form and not waste God's good bounty because of man's artificial pricing.
Then there is this horrendous penalty of $2 million fine and jail term up to 7 years for what, carrying milk powder!
What does all this say about China, the world's second largest economy. Can't produce enough milk powder for its citizens, and whatever they produce, their own citizens can't trust them not to taint their food products with whatever additives to increase their profit margin.
So isn't it really a great joke if it was not such a sad and sorry tale after all?

Pages

Login

SCMP.com Account

or