• Sat
  • Dec 20, 2014
  • Updated: 9:44am
NewsHong Kong

Poll ‘primary’ was my idea and not Beijing's, says Rita Fan

Veteran politician says she has no idea how Beijing views 2017 election, after media storm about possible screening of chief executive candidates

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 14 March, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Thursday, 14 March, 2013, 9:05am

A veteran Hong Kong deputy to the National People's Congress says her suggestion that a "primary" be held to select candidates for the next chief executive race is only her personal opinion and does not represent Beijing's view.

Rita Fan Hsu Lai-tai, who is expected to be elected as a member of the NPC's Standing Committee today, said her idea was aimed at shortlisting hopefuls for the vote in 2017 - the first time Hong Kong's leader will be chosen by universal suffrage - rather than stopping pan-democrats or anyone unacceptable to the central government from entering the race. "Some people may have the impression that the system is aimed at [ousting pan-democrats], but it is not what I mean," she said.

Article 45 of the Basic Law calls for a "broadly representative" nominating committee to forward chief executive candidates for a popular vote in line with "democratic procedures".

Fan said the "democratic procedures" could involve "a voting process" among committee members or "a primary".

Speaking at a gathering of journalists in Beijing yesterday, she said: "I think a primary could be one of the many options, but it is not an authoritative interpretation [of the article] … I have no idea what Beijing is thinking, and I haven't talked to them."

Fan said the primary could ensure there would not be "too many candidates", which may confuse voters and hinder candidates from elaborating on their election platforms in televised forums. But she declined to say what would be an appropriate number of candidates.

Fan also refused to comment on whether a public consultation on the election should be launched in October, as suggested on Tuesday by former chief secretary Henry Tang Ying-yen.

A media storm over whether a screening mechanism should be set up erupted on Sunday when Ming Pao Daily quoted "an authoritative person close to the central government" as saying such a mechanism was needed to bar candidates not acceptable to Beijing from running in the 2017 chief executive election. This fuelled speculation that the person was representing the views of the central government or testing the waters for such a move.

Fan declined to confirm if she was the person quoted by Ming Pao, but admitted hosting an off-the-record media gathering on Saturday.

"I made it clear that what I was going to say must not be used for reporting, so I won't disclose what I had said during the lunch," Fan said.

"When I read the news report [on Sunday], I thought 'that could not be me' because there are things that I had not said and the term [an authoritative person] doesn't fit me either, because … I really have no idea what the central government is thinking."

On Sunday, the secretary for constitutional and mainland affairs, Raymond Tam Chi-yuen, said no concrete plans were in place for the 2017 election and the government had yet to start its "five step" consultation.

Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying said on Tuesday that the government would start the consultation at a "suitable time".

Fan suggested her outspoken style could lose her some support. "If I am re-elected [to the Standing Committee] with far fewer votes in favour of me, and more votes against me, it will be worth some self-evaluation."



More on this story

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

What I have learnt from this article is when Rita Fan says something right it is Beijing's view and when Rita Fan says something wrong it is her view! Surely Rita Fan is experienced enough in politics to clarify from the outset whether it is her view or Beijing’s view. If she doesn’t she can leave herself wide open to accusations that she was testing the water for Beijing. In other words, if no fuss was made about conducting a primary this would give Beijing a clear signal to progress down this route.
hard times !
This Old Hong Kong agrees with what you said that what Rita Fan claimed that it was her own view if the response of her words was negative or unwelcome here in Hong Kong.Yet if the response of a 'primary poll' or a screening scheme got no strong objection, then it might smoothly go on ! How wicked/cunning this old lady is ! Her identity is and used to be a standing committee member of the Chinese People Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC)---can easily approach the leaders in Beijing than most Hong Kong people---how can she have her personal views ? I wonder. Don't fool us any more !
hard times !
Mrs.Rita Fan Tsui Lei-tai is never a commoner like this old Hong Kong.Instead she has become a public figures for years.In the British colonial days, she was first appointed into the then Legislative Council, then the Executive Council.After the Handover,she was elected to be the chairperson of the Temporary Legco. Soon she became the chairwoman of Legco through internal election. After stepping down from that prestigious post, she turned into an elected Legislator before appointed/elected as a standing committee member of the Chinese People Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC) and is highed tipped to remain in this highly prestigious post this year.Her present post used to be held by old patriot tycoon Tsang Hin-tze,boss of Goldion.Tsang was familiar with the leaders in Beijing while holding that post.Now Mrs.Fan claimed that the 'primary poll' of the candidates in our universal suffrage in 2017 of our chief executive was just her personal opinion only and not represents Beijing's, can you believe it ? Mrs.Fan, when will you be more honest towards your Hong Kong compatriots and speak your minds as usual even facing the temptation of power ?
hard times !
this old woman is lying in broad daylight. Don't be fooled by her words which sound gentle and nice on the surface----actually this woman is sly and cunning enough---not poorer than C.Y. in this field indeed.Her so-called personal views actually represent her identity----a standing committe member of the Chinese People Political Consultative Conference which allows her easy access to have talks with state leaders or at least senior cadres both in Beijing and here in Hong Kong.Remember her predecessor,Tsing Hin-tze who was once seen on TV approaching the standing committe members of the Poliburo at People's Hall and greeted each one of them and receiving nice response.How honourable Mrs.Fan's post is, just less than national leaders (such as C.H.Tung) only.


SCMP.com Account