• Sat
  • Jul 26, 2014
  • Updated: 11:38pm
NewsHong Kong
SOCIETY

We love our neighbours, but only if they're like us

More than 7 out of 10 Hongkongers would not like to live next to people of a different race - the highest percentage in worldwide survey

PUBLISHED : Friday, 17 May, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Friday, 17 May, 2013, 5:54am

What's going on in "Asia's World City"? A whole lot of racism, it seems, at least if a new world map on people's attitudes towards race is to be believed.

When asked the question "Who would you not like to have as a neighbour?", 71.8 per cent of Hongkongers said they would not want to live next to people of a different race, the highest figure in a survey covering 81 countries that was published in The Washington Post on Wednesday.

Respondents were given choices for their answer, such as people of a different race, criminals, drug addicts, and those of different religious backgrounds, and asked to choose.

I also think this example doesn't give Hong Kong people enough credit. There are a lot of things that Hong Kong people are more tolerant of that other people aren't elsewhere in the world. For instance, Islam isn't a contentious issue in Hong Kong

The figures, part of a survey by the World Values Survey Association that used the same methodology worldwide, place Hong Kong in an unflattering light.

In comparison, 43.5 per cent of Indians, 51.4 per cent of Jordanians and 71.7 per cent of Bangladeshis said the same. In most places the figure was below 40.

The local data is from a 2005 questionnaire by Hong Kong University sociologist Ng Chun-hung on behalf of the project.

While people on social media sites were quick to point out examples that supported the results, experts had another view.

"It's a fair representation of what was going on eight years ago," said Paul O'Connor, assistant professor of anthropology at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. "But in the last few years things have changed, with tension between mainland Chinese and Hong Kong Chinese."

Because cosmopolitan and Western influences are qualities Hongkongers use to distinguish themselves from mainland Chinese, instances of racism are now less common against those who look different, he said.

"I also think this example doesn't give Hong Kong people enough credit. There are a lot of things that Hong Kong people are more tolerant of that other people aren't elsewhere in the world. For instance, Islam isn't a contentious issue in Hong Kong."

But he added: "It's still the case that the darker the skin colour the greater the prejudice ... It's still tough for ethnic minorities here."

Fermi Wong Wai-fun, of rights group Unison, and a long-term advocate of minority rights, said the findings were consistent with those of her organisation. "I know that Hong Kong doesn't have a race policy, and we're more about promoting Chinese culture than anything, but I'm surprised it's so high," she said.

But she added that part of the reason could be that the concept of neighbours in one country is different to that of a densely populated place like Hong Kong: "For Canada your neighbour might be 100 metres down the road, here you're window to window."

The Equal Opportunities Commission said it could not comment on the figures as they were unsure of the survey methodology, but said surveys done by the commission and the government do not seem to support the theory that racial tolerance is low.

 

WORLD CITY?

Hongkongers surveyed didn't want to live next door to:

  • Drug addicts (10 per cent)
  • Heavy drinkers (16 per cent)
  • Emotionally unstable people (17 per cent)
  • People with a criminal record (42.4 per cent)
  • People who have Aids (43.1 per cent)
  • Homosexuals (48.6 per cent)
  • People of a different race (71.8 per cent)
  • Immigrants/foreign workers (78 per cent)

 

Share

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive
 
 

 

13

This article is now closed to comments

shouken
I do not quite agree that Confucianism is any less cosmopolitan or public-spirited than the other major religious or social creeds. The story of Meng Tze's mother, even if not to be taken as fabricated literary embellishment for narrative impact, does not make her any more (or less) of a racist (or discriminationist) than most others, western or oriental. We all discriminate on various accounts and partake of "birds of a feather flock together" phenomenon, and not only at choosing neighbors. The difference between orientals and westerners is small, especially if one factors in variations in local situations, as you pointed out.
johnyuan
What modern Chinese have partaken Confucianism, I suspect not so different from the past is partial and overlook what cosmopolitan or public-spirited it may contain. Meng Tze’s story learned by school children in school needs no ground to validate of its authenticity. All bear no contribution towards counter argument. Our selective exposure to our past has form who we are.
johnyuan
Chinese behavior is subliminally influenced by Confucianism of which one’s social value begins from home than extends outward to public at large. It will not be so surprising Chinese are more sensitive (prejudice) against anyone who is an outsider. Furthermore, the extraordinary urban density where social distance is only window to window with one’s neighbor is an excellent observation. It certainly contributes to the high score for Hong Kong being sensitive who lives next door. Not to mention also the story that Meng Tze’s mother relocated the family three times for better neighborhood. Well, the claim of a world city may be is conditional for Hong Kong where the majority is Chinese. New York City seems put more effort to undo the saying ‘birds of a feather flock together’ in choosing neighbors.

Pages

 
 
 
 
 

Login

SCMP.com Account

or