• Sat
  • Sep 20, 2014
  • Updated: 5:19am
Edward Snowden
NewsHong Kong

Hong Kong minister rejects US accusations of deliberately delaying Snowden's arrest

US failed to provide information vital to processing whistle-blower's arrest

PUBLISHED : Tuesday, 25 June, 2013, 9:21pm
UPDATED : Wednesday, 26 June, 2013, 5:29am

Hong Kong’s justice secretary said on Tuesday the United States had failed to provide crucial information necessary to support its request for the arrest of whistle-blower Edward Snowden before he had left the city.

The missing information included things as basic as a confirmation of Snowden’s full name and passport number, Secretary for Justice Rimsky Yuen Kwok-keung said on Tuesday.

“Up to the moment Snowden left the city, the US government had not replied to the Department of Justice’s request for the necessary information,” he said.

There was no legal basis to restrict or ban Mr Snowden from leaving Hong Kong
Secretary for Justice, Rimsky Yuen Kwok-keung

“Therefore, it was impossible and there was no legal basis under Hong Kong law for the Department of Justice to ask a Hong Kong judge to sign off on a provisional arrest warrant,” Yuen said. “[Thus] there then was no legal basis to restrict or ban Mr Snowden from leaving Hong Kong.”

Yuen’s public remarks – his first on the Snowden case – came after the White House said it was disappointed with the city’s failure to arrest the fugitive whistle-blower who has made public information detailing US internet spying programmes around the world.

Snowden left Hong Kong on Sunday and is believed to be in a transit area of a Moscow airport. The former CIA contractor had previously told the Post in an exclusive report that the US had been hacking into computers in Hong Kong and China since 2009.

Yuen said the US government had not responded to Hong Kong’s request for a confirmation of Mr Snowden name and passport number even though it had mentioned that he was a US passport holder, Yuen said.

The name used in US government diplomatic documents was Edward James Snowden, the US Department of Justice referred to him as Edward J Snowden, and Hong Kong’s Immigration Department had him recorded as Edward Joseph Snowden, Yuen said.

“I couldn’t say the three names were consistent, so we needed further clarification. Otherwise, there would have been legal problems with a provisional arrest warrant,” Yuen said.

The US also failed to explain to Hong Kong authorities how two of the three charges the US mentioned in its arrest request fell within the scope of a US-Hong Kong rendition of fugitive offenders agreement signed in 1996.

The Hong Kong government on June 15 received the US request for the provisional arrest of Snowden on three charges, namely unauthorised disclosure of national defence information, unauthorised disclosure of intelligence and stealing state property.

Yuen said the US had failed to tell Hong Kong authorities which part of the agreement covered the first two charges.

He also said documents from the US made no mention of what evidence they had against Snowden, a requirement for Hong Kong courts to move ahead with a provisional arrest.

Yuen chronicled the process of how Hong Kong had been dealing with a US request for the provisional arrest of Snowden starting from June 15. He rejected US suggestions that Hong Kong had been employing delaying tactics.

Any suggestion that we deliberately let Mr Snowden get away and had done anything to obstruct normal operations is totally untrue

“We had not been deliberately delaying the process. All along, we have acted in full accordance with the law,” Yuen said.

“And any suggestion that we deliberately let Mr Snowden get away and had done anything to obstruct normal operations is totally untrue.”

He said that on June 17, Hong Kong e-mailed the US Department of Justice, saying that it was drafting a list of questions for clarifications and further details needed to process the request.

Yuen said that on June 21 – two days before Snowden left — the Security Bureau wrote to the US government asking it to clarify reports that the US had been hacking into computers in Hong Kong.

On the same afternoon, Hong Kong’s Department of Justice e-mailed and sent by speed-post to the US its request for further information to support the US request for the provisional arrest of Snowden.

As of Tuesday, Hong Kong had not received a reply from the US to this request.

 

Share

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive
 
 

 

46

This article is now closed to comments

Sticks Evans
All lawyers are hacks
major.dickason.9
Your HK Minister is Full of ****
major.dickason.9
s H I T
Carioca no Coracao
funny...
snobby.boner
I hope the whole international community suppoits Snowden. In USA he is a HERO.. it is on the Obama gansters that make him look bad.. because he made them look bad, and they are. Obama is a war crominal and a corrupt niggero and should be impeached, charged with treason and no one would care if he was put in a jail cell for rest of his life..except the niggeros that will loose all their free stuff
hard times !
Hong Kong didn't kowtow to the pressure of Uncle Sam, so did Beijing and now Russia which has no so-called extradition treaty with America but instead their relationship is quite sour and hostile to each other, I dare say.Even the small nations in the western hemishphere like Cuba,Venezuela and Ecuador have no respects towards this World Cop who is debt-ridden (with a national debt of astronomical figure) and can only print more and more greenbacks to pay for her huge expenditures on military fields.This time,Obama is both' insulted' and embarrassed by so many nations and places for a young fellow countryman named Edward Snowden who revealed his secret cyber-spying program:The Prism that angers all the nations in the world for hacking is a crime and unfriend act indeed.How can you expect others to help a thief who broke into their houses ?! The Obama administration is just naive enough to believe that 'might is right' !
jasonmitman1
Once again this goes to show that America is not the super power that this Government want's to believe they are, the rest of the wold is just laughing at them. If America was so strong and had so much sway in the world today, do you not think these other countries would have made this happen for America? Instead they just said tough luck, and remember the treaties are due to be resigned here soon that should throw a whole other interesting wrench in this saga for America...
babyhenry
This day will be the day HK stood up for everyone whose privacy and rights is being violated by a shamless hyprocritical mass murdering gov't, piper. I know you are **** because your spine is aching from trying to stand straight.
SenSen
You can't accept that even as a movie plot! What a shame!
dlapiper
This will go down in history as when the "two systems" were practically dispensed with and Hong Kong became integrated into the PRC propaganda machine. The comments of Rimsky Yuen and his fellow comrades insult the intelligence of my primary school children.
Think what you will of the US and its Prism programme, but this will be an indelible stain on Hong Kong's standing in the world.

Pages

 
 
 
 
 

Login

SCMP.com Account

or