• Wed
  • Oct 15, 2014
  • Updated: 5:19pm
NewsHong Kong

Muslim student presses CUHK for halal canteen

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 11 July, 2013, 12:28pm
UPDATED : Thursday, 11 July, 2013, 3:31pm

Celebrating the first day of Ramadan - a month of fasting for Muslims worldwide, Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK) student Wang Yunan on Monday revealed his frustrations in living in one of Asia’s most diverse campuses.

In a letter addressed to CUHK’s Vice-Chancellor Joseph Sung, Wang appealed to the university to build a Muslim canteen that offers halal food - food prepared and cooked under Islamic dietary guidelines.

“I know the Muslim community is small,” Wang wrote in the letter. “But CUHK is known for its diversity and respect for minorities, and I believe the university can do better.”

Growing up a “pious” Muslim in Beijing, Wang has spent the past year pursuing a graduate degree in intercultural studies at CUHK. With no Muslim cafes available on campus and the nearest halal food eatery 30 minutes’ train ride away, Wang said he had stuck to a daily diet of chicken and vegetables in the past year. 

Wang said he was not particularly proud of his diet because it was not strictly halal. Besides pork, Muslims are prohibited from eating animals that are "dead prior to slaughtering", or "not slaughtered in the name of Allah", according to the Koran.

The fact that Hong Kong University, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, and Hong Kong Polytechnic University all have Muslim canteens or halal food sections also encouraged Wang to press his alma mater to upgrade its facilities.

Wang even carried out a survey to collect opinions from students and staff regarding a Muslim canteen. When a university cafeteria manager told him it would  take approximately 10 years for CUHK to approve such a plan, Wang was shocked.

“Just imagine how many Muslim students, teachers and visiting scholars will be disappointed during this 10 years when they come to CUHK, ” he wrote in the letter.

“Muslims students at CUHK would appreciate some halal options on campus," said Chinese University anthropology lecturer Paul O'Connor and author of the book Islam in Hong Kong. "It would reflect the university's dynamic international nature, its open and inclusive ethos, and its ecumenical spirit.” 

O'Connor said students had told him of their difficulty in finding halal food on campus. "Often students will choose to eat vegetarian food in order to maintain a halal diet," he said. 

More than a quarter of a million Muslims live and work in Hong Kong, according to findings by O'Connor. While many come from families who have lived here for generations, others are new immigrants and migrant workers. 

CUHK’s Joseph Sung didn’t respond to the South China Morning Post’s request for an interview on Tuesday.


More on this story

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Thanks Wang for bring this up and proud of CUHK as always.
I graduated from New Asia College CUHK 10 yrs ago and I convert to Islam 4 years ago when I worked in London. Halal food is just one example of providing an environment for cultural exchange and attracting international speakers. In fact there are almost 25% muslim population in the world. One of the reason Hong Kong is falling behind other Asia cities in some survey I believe is people's lack of worldwide vision. Islamic financing was a hot topic a few years ago but why it did't work in Hong Kong and now it's almost too late and the market share went to Singapore, KL, London even Thailand? We just don't have the infrastructure. The ratio of vegetarian restaurant to pure vegetarian is way higher than halal restaurant to Muslims population. In almost every trade fair in mainland you'll found halal corner. In HSBC London and many big corporations you have halal corner. The world is a global village and university is a good start for mutual respect and understanding.
P.S Muslims also eat kosher food (jewish) and pure vegetarian food. Well, it is hard not to eat meat at all, but you can also recommend the supermarket to stock some meat for cooking in hostel.
See you around if you are going to attend the 10-year Alumni gathering in Aug 13.
[“Just imagine how many Muslim students, teachers and visiting scholars will be disappointed during this 10 years when they come to CUHK, ” he wrote in the letter.]

Yes, how many? Please enlighten us. How many students and teachers at CUHK out of the 23,000 campus population are indeed muslim? 20? 50? 100?

Why on earth does the university have to build a whole new canteen to serve halal food? Surely they can serve a halal dish or two in the existing canteens? Should we also build special canteens for vegetarians? Or for people who really like mango? What about a dedicated cafe for cappuccino affectionados?

It would seem fair to me to ask that CUHK's canteens serve food that matches the dietary preferences (whether they are based on religious beliefs or not) of the student and teaching body. However, demanding that a secular institution build a canteen specifically for one religious group is many bridges too far.

If Mr Wang longs for that kind of special treatment, let him go study in Saudi Arabia.
Respect cannot be demanded but earned. It is dangerous to impose one's faith upon others. People who do not share the same faith may still be friends. Nevertheless, tolerance is fair and objective. By the way, forgiveness is the beginning of peace.
Dirt Man
This is just another example of Muslim entitlement. What about Jews? What about vegetarians? What about people on ketogenic diets or who have gluten allergies?
Make your own food at home and stop complaining. The world cannot tailor to suit your every need.


SCMP.com Account