• Sun
  • Oct 26, 2014
  • Updated: 9:17am
NewsHong Kong

US consul Clifford Hart gets another blast from Beijing over democracy

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 26 September, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Thursday, 26 September, 2013, 3:49pm

Washington's top envoy in Hong Kong might have thought he was being careful when he said on Tuesday that the US would not take sides when it came to the city's democratic development.

But Clifford Hart's comments in his first public speech in his new role managed to reignite Beijing's anger.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs yesterday again told the US to stay out of Hong Kong affairs.

While Hart said Washington supported "genuine universal suffrage" but had "no prescription" when it came to democratic development, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said no other country should have any say in the city's constitutional development.

"The issue of political development is Hong Kong's internal affair, and China's internal politics," ministry spokesman Hong Lei said. "No countries should make irresponsible remarks. We request that the relevant countries align their words with their actions, and do more that helps Hong Kong become prosperous and stable."

The Beijing-loyalist Wen Wei Po published an editorial saying Hart could be "facing a gloomy ending if he continues meddling in Hong Kong's political development". It said: "Clifford Hart has ignored a warning from the Chinese government and is blatantly intervening in the city's political development. Such an act is a violation of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations."

It was referring to the treaty that forbids diplomats from interfering in the internal affairs of host states. In May, the Foreign Ministry also quoted the document in a warning to Hart's predecessor, Stephen Young.

The daily pointed an accusing finger at an invitation the consulate posted on Facebook on the 50th anniversary of Martin Luther King's "I have a dream" speech, asking people what their dream was. Most of those who posted replies said they wanted an independent Hong Kong.



For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

that son of a **** hates hong kong , he should not be born an american he is a mentally ill arab a sick semite he does not deserve to be an american
Beijing needs to pick better people to handle external affairs. US officials normally accuse China of being undemocratic. Now here comes Hart with some cautious statements and he is blasted for that. What would Beijing expect him to say? Oh, you guys are right and can do whatever you wish? This isnt the US's style so Beijing should react only when they really believe foreign powers are intervening. Frankly, I personally feel Hart's statements indicates the US is adopting a hands-off approach.
Hart should just shut up. China doesn't need his endorsement, or not.
The best thing for these American diplomats (another term for expatriates with a nothing-to-do overseas job) is to simply "Shut Up".................
The CCP continues to demonstrate, with these overreactions, that they are more panicky and weak than anyone thought. They must be assuming its all over for them by Christmas
The Chinese Communist Party speaks from, and demonstrates by these repeated testy retorts, a position of fear, constant fear of the tide of free speech which will ultimately wash them away.
Why should you think it is fear? Why should the US comment on anything China does? China doesnt comment on US affairs. China is saying 'mind your own business', and quite righty too.
And the US govt speaks no lies ( wmd iraq, syria ) & holds no fear, totally secure ( NSA surv ).
Get real ianson.
And yet Beijing has no problem commenting on US internal policies. Perhaps they should pass their issues along to the new complaint desk at State. It is staffed by Ms. Helen Waite. If they have a complaint, feel free to go to Helen Waite.
Idiot. Do u see the chinese envoy in US commenting anything ?
Think before you comment dumb ****




SCMP.com Account