• Fri
  • Dec 19, 2014
  • Updated: 8:42am
NewsHong Kong

Anger over HK$90 rise in monthly minimum wage for domestic workers

Disappointed unions say new minimum wage is still only HK$150 more than it was 15 years ago and predict it will deepen shortage of recruits

PUBLISHED : Monday, 30 September, 2013, 9:37pm
UPDATED : Tuesday, 01 October, 2013, 10:44am


  • Yes: 18%
  • No: 82%
1 Oct 2013
  • Yes
  • No
Total number of votes recorded: 318

Domestic helpers who sign contracts from today will get an additional HK$90 a month after a government decision that upset the workers but pleased their employers.

The new monthly minimum wage is HK$4,010 and helpers whose bosses do not provide food will have their monthly allowance raised by HK$45 to HK$920 a month.

Helpers' unions said that after reductions and freezes during recent tough economic times, the new wage was only HK$150 a month above the 1998 level.

Eman Villanueva, spokesman for the Asian Migrants' Co-ordinating Body, was "very disappointed and angered" by the 2.3 per cent increase and said the supply of helpers would become even more restricted.

He said he made it clear to the Labour Department at a recent meeting that monthly minimum pay should rise to HK$4,500.

But Joseph Law Kwan-din, chairman of the Hong Kong Employers of Overseas Domestic Helpers Association, said the government had taken employers' ability to pay into consideration.

He said Hong Kong should still be able to recruit a sufficient number of helpers because of poorer employment conditions in places such as Taiwan, where helpers are given fewer public holidays off.

A government spokesman said the increase was set "after careful consideration of the economic indicators".

He said it was also necessary to strike a balance between what employers could afford and the livelihoods of the helpers.

Helen Bulusan, who has been working in the city for 11 years, said she was very disappointed.

She said some helpers needed to spend HK$1,200 a month on food because employers offered only simple meals such as bread.

Along with other expenses such as phone bills, many helpers had only HK$2,500 left at the end of the month.

Villanueva said a bigger pay rise was justified because of high inflation. He said the wage level had not risen sufficiently over the years and pointed out it was HK$3,860 in 1998.

"I think the shortage [of helpers] will worsen because the wage is not attractive," he said.

"In Canada, the minimum wage for foreign domestic helpers is the same as for the locals.

"New York and California have also approved a bill of rights to give the same minimum wage level to locals and to foreign domestic workers."

The minimum wage in Canada differs among provinces, but it is about C$10 (HK$75) an hour.

The minimum monthly wages for helpers in Taiwan and Singapore are about HK$4,100 and HK$3,000 respectively.

There are more than 300,000 foreign helpers in Hong Kong at present, mainly from the Philippines and Indonesia.

As the governments in Manila and Jakarta are planning policies to discourage their citizens from working as helpers overseas, agencies are looking to Bangladesh for new recruits.

There are currently about 100 Bangladeshi helpers in the city.

Technic Employment Service Centre chief Teresa Liu Tsui-lan said Hongkongers were once able to choose helpers from several candidates, but now had to take those offered by agencies.



For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

please don't listen to the demands of these sucking maids. this bullying and threatening should not be accepted. don't be dependent on these maids who in realty only come here to enjoy and not work. these maids are worried about their phone bills. why will the employer bear their luxury expenses. the citizens of hong kong don't get enough jobs and salaries and these maids expect employers to increase their salaries otherwise they will not work. are they out of their mind. this threatening of eman vellaneuva will not be accepted.get out of hong kong if you are not satisfied by the pay and work
Your last sentence is unwarranted. If anything, many expressed the view that they did not mind paying more if the standard of service improved! They are also paying the recruitment fee, medical insurance, airfares, in addition to the salaries, so that the total cost is considerable, not just the $4010 per month. Given that the helpers only get one day a week off work, most of their living costs are provided by the employers. Employers who are obliged to change their domestic helpers because of unsatisfactory service during a contract of employment are out of pocket considerably. We hear from the articulate helpers of their unfair plight. Some employers have grievances too, including cases of maids putting menstrual blood in soups for the mistresses, and sulking if they don't get their way, or if they are asked to stay in to help with special occasions like Chinese New Year.
By the way, I am not among the 10% wealthiest people in HK, nor do I have a domestic helper.
jesus you are clearly mentally unstable...
Agree. If Canada pays better, the domestic helpers can choose to go there. Why expect HK to match Canadian conditions? Please note that the phone bills would be even higher.
I recall that the poverty line is an income of $3600 per month for a single person. From this sum, the poor person has to pay rent, transport, food, electricity, water, clothing etc. A very sad existence. A domestic helper will get $4010 per month, PLUS housing, food, electricity, water, transport, medical insurance, airfares per contract. And she is still complaining?
IRDHK is quite right, I think. The middle class, not top bosses, has been far too lethargic in accepting unsociable long hours to cater to the needs of their bosses to the detriment of their families. If this was only an exception then it wouldn't matter but the fact that it is the norm is detrimental to society as a whole now and in the future. A simple solution would be to set a standard working week. Bosses can then decide if they want to pay overtime. And before the 'Business Before Family Brigade' start crying foul I would simply say one word phrase to you - Improved Efficiency. Measure efficiency and improve it. Efficiency doesn't mean asking your secretary to do your shopping for you because you say you can't trust your maid!
The proposed increase is 2.3%. Did you think local workers get a phenomenal raise annually from their employers? And they face the full brunt of the increased cost of living in HK, whereas domestic helpers appear from another comment here to be exposed mainly to the cost of phone bills. DHs are employed to cook, wash etc., and have been assessed by the Govt to be worth a specific salary. If you don't agree with it, by all means choose another profession or place of work. There is no need to denigrate the HK public.
Interesting. People who read SCMP are most likely western or have lived in the West. Comments below are well written thus those commenting are at least University trained. People who read SCMP.com have the disposable cash to do so. Thus everyone in this Forum are from the top 10% of wealthiest people in HK.
The vast majority of comments on SCMP.com seem to reflect the view that domestic helpers receive a competive wage and enjoy a fairly good standard of living.
I just wonder what they must be saying on baby kingdom and Apple daily. I can only assume people are very upset that domestic helpers wages were not lowered by 10%.
Yes, after reading your comments, you are the living proof of your first point, which is very sad but true: "the readership has an intelligence of less than average." It is a self-fulfilling prophecy.
sontan0917: your ranting and raving clearly indicates that you are a rabid, misinformed bigot. Go away and refrain from polluting these pages with your nonsense.



SCMP.com Account