• Sat
  • Dec 27, 2014
  • Updated: 8:17pm
NewsHong Kong

Doubts about expat tipped to be HKU head

Recommendation for new vice-chancellor is questioned by president of staff association

PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 02 October, 2013, 12:00am
UPDATED : Wednesday, 02 October, 2013, 2:34am

The prospect that the University of Hong Kong could have its first expatriate vice-chancellor in a decade was called into question yesterday when the staff association expressed "disappointment" at the idea.

Stephen Chan Chit-kwai, president of the staff association, which represents about 2,000 people, said he was worried that Professor Peter William Mathieson lacked the desired academic standing and management experience to succeed Professor Tsui Lap-chee.

The university announced on Monday that Mathieson, now dean of medicine and dentistry at the University of Bristol, had been recommended by an 11-member selection committee to become the 102-year-old institution's next head.

"I am a bit disappointed, because it has taken so long and they only managed to find someone like [Mathieson]," Chan said.

"He doesn't have a very high academic standing, there's some distance between [him] and Tsui."

Tsui was a highly regarded geneticist before becoming the 14th vice-chancellor.

"Regarding management experience, [Mathieson] wasn't even a pro-vice-chancellor … I talked to a professor from our medical school and he also thinks [Mathieson's] curriculum vitae is ordinary," Chan said.

Mathieson will meet the university's staff, students, alumni, and senate on Friday before meeting the university's governing council, which will decide whether to endorse the selection committee's recommendation. Chan said he wanted to ask Mathieson how, as a British scholar, he would overcome cultural differences and ensure effective communication with relevant stakeholders.

But he would not strongly oppose the recommendation because many staff members were hoping the selection could be completed before Tsui's term ends in February. He said he believed it likely the council would approve the panel's choice.

Speaking after yesterday's National Day reception, Dr Leong Che-hung, who chairs both the committee and the council, said the latter would not be a rubber stamp.

"It could say 'no'," Leong said. "We will consider the views of staff, students and alumni … it is a very democratic process."

He suggested that Mathieson's interpersonal skills could help him handle politically sensitive issues.

If appointed, Mathieson will become HKU's first non-Chinese vice-chancellor since Professor William Ian Rees Davies, who headed the institution from 2000 to 2002; and its second since Dr Kenneth Robinson's tenure from 1965 to 1972.


More on this story

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

You do know that notoriety means being famous for doing something bad? Mathieson's predecessor gained notoriety by shoe-shiningly inviting a bunch of robber baron tycoons ahead of academics at a ceremony for Li in 2011, bringing shame on himself and his institution. Mathieson would have to show catastrophically bad judgement to match the notoriety Tsui gained for his toadying behaviour.
No. I believe in the reason given, that Mathieson's performance is ordinary. If he wasn't even Pro-Vice-Chancellor at home, how can he be Vice-Chancellor in HK? After all, HK has standards to maintain!!!
To echo the previous comment, I do not agree that Mathieson is the "wrong race". However, one of the main problems is that Professor Mathieson lacks both academic achievements and worldwide notoriety. Mathieson does not even come close to his predecessor. This is a devastating disappointment and definitely a huge step backwards for the university.
It would be a lot more edifying if the nationalistic Mr Chan just came right out and said what his real problem with Mathieson is: he's the wrong race. No amount of pretence that Mathieson has an undistinguished academic record (he doesn't) is going to effectively disguise the racism at the core of this complaint.
Just one more dismal illustration of why Hong Kong is far from any reasonable definition of a World City.
Are you really not aware of the stepping stone nature of moving upwards from job to job? Mathieson has a fine academic record and the appropriate experience to take the reins at HKU, an institution that's far from being in the international first rank.


SCMP.com Account