• Sat
  • Dec 20, 2014
  • Updated: 1:12pm
NewsHong Kong

Aquino apologises – for forgetting Hong Kong chief executive’s name

PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 23 October, 2013, 10:39pm
UPDATED : Thursday, 24 October, 2013, 6:29pm

Philippine President Benigno Aquino finally said sorry to Hong Kong yesterday - not for the Manila hostage bloodbath but for forgetting the name of Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying, whom he met earlier this month.

Aquino stuck to his refusal to apologise to the hostage victims and their families, and admitted that fears of a legal backlash were a consideration. But he said some of the policemen who botched the rescue of Hongkongers from a hijacked tourist bus in Manila in 2010 could get harsher penalties.

Video: Philippine president: There will be no apologies for Hong Kong over bus hostage tragedy

The president's apology came during a foreign press forum in Manila when he was asked if, on the sidelines of the recent Asean summit in Brunei, he had discussed Hong Kong's concerns with Premier Li Keqiang .

Aquino rejected a China News Service report that Li had told him to find a way to resolve the dispute, saying: "I didn't talk to him about the Hong Kong issue.

"We talked in passing, as opposed to a formal bilateral meeting," he said, adding that most of the discussion had to do with disputes in the South China Sea.

"I talked to the chief executive of the SAR - I'm sorry and I apologise, the name escapes me at this point in time - wherein he explained their perspectives and I explained our perspectives."

I talked to the chief executive of the SAR - I'm sorry and I apologise, the name escapes me at this point in time

Asked if the possibility of a legal backlash was deterring him from formally apologising, he said: "That has to be a consideration." An apology would imply that the hostage-taking was an act of state, and "then the idea also of compensation comes in".

"Our position is that the act of one individual who was probably mentally unstable should not be construed as an act of the entire country. We offered again our condolences to all who suffered and died. But there are limitations from a legalistic point of view."

Still, Aquino said his government was serious about bringing closure to the issue.

"I think the … current thinking is to increase the penalties for several policemen involved."

However, he said ex-Manila mayor Alfredo Lim might escape punishment, though he left his post at a crucial time and his order to arrest hostage-taker Rolando Mendoza's brother unwittingly set off the killing frenzy. He said the police commander ultimately was responsible, since he could have ignored Lim's suggestions.

Separately, the Security Bureau said it had "initial contact" with Manila City Council member Bernardito Ang, representing mayor Joseph Estrada, about arranging a meeting with bureau officials to apologise to the victims' families and survivors.

Ang said the city legislature was "sincere" in apologising regardless of what the Manila did.

"This incident took place in Manila. If something happened in Hong Kong, the central government wouldn't apologise."

But Tse Chi-kin, brother of slain tour guide Masa Tse Ting-chunn, said Aquino should say sorry, too.

Additional reporting by Phila Siu and Stuart Lau



For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

As in all tragedies of this kind, a chain of events went wrong:
There was no organised operational control;
The commander of police on the scene decided to handle the matter himself with an ill equipped team untrained for this type of operation, hence they took about 30 minutes to get into the bus;
There was available within call a properly trained expert team with the right equipment and training to enter the bus and neutralise the gunman quickly, probably within 5 seconds, but they were not called in;
The media and other non-involved personnel were not excluded from the crime scene, which was thus not controlled, so the gunman could watch live on the tv inside the bus what the assault team was doing outside the bus, raising his stress levels;
The final assault failed from the point of view that hostages were killed.
President Aquino could defuse the situation by saying he deeply regrets what happened and acknowledging that, while the direct cause of the deaths was an unstable gunman, the police could have handled the affair better.
These deaths, or at least many of them, could have been avoided.
James To is handling the matter very badly. He has raised exhorbitant demands which if accepted can only humiliate the Philippines Government and people. He knows no Chinese would accept such terms so why is he doing this?
This mindless idiot has not only not taken responsiblity for decisions made by his untrained police force and the mayor of Manila, he has laughted about 8 Hong Kong people being killed in cold blood. Are Hong Kong people wrong to seek justice?
so this is the president of a country, scary to think about all those below him
Aquino doesn't need to remember CY Leung's name. He should just call him "Sir". Like so many of his country's citizens know, that's the proper way for a Filipino to address a Hong Kong male.
The whole incident is valuable in telling us what kind of a country the Philippinnes is, what its culture is, and why as a nation it will never be strong and successful. The thought of dropping the demand for an apology is shortsighted. If someone escapes any punishment for making a big mistake, he will be encouraged to do it again. We shouldn't bury our heads in the sand.
Aquino is playing with words in saying the Premier didnt talk to him at APEC. The Premier must have conveyed some message to him on the issue though not necessarily in person during their meeting at APECotherwise Mr. Smiley-face will continue to snub HK. I dont believe much in what this guy Aquino says. Just a week or so ago he claimed that CY had agreed not to pursue the matter and later blamed their local press for misinterpretation. Come off it man. You can stick to your guns about offering neither apology nor compensation but these dirty underhand tactics should not come from a head of state.
Look at who we are dealing with here. Aquino is a worthless puke. Any apology from him means nothing. He should compensate the families of the victims and move on. But in his pinheaded mind he thinks he is being asked to apologize for what the lone gunman did rather than the bungled rescue attempt and the lack of justice for the irresponsible decisions that led to the deaths of 8 Hongkongers.
He may not be answerable to the HK people but if what he says or does affects HK people we have a right to demand answers. Acting so smugly doesnt exactly put you in a good light.
Look on the bright side, I just wish the Hong Kong people would have the same luxury of being as forgetful of his name. CY who?
Many in HK would like to forget his name too.



SCMP.com Account