• Mon
  • Apr 21, 2014
  • Updated: 8:01pm
NewsHong Kong

Manila bus tragedy compensation plan differs from families' expectations

Bereaved families' representative says amount offered differs from victims' expectations

PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 30 October, 2013, 4:27am
UPDATED : Wednesday, 30 October, 2013, 9:06am

The Manila city government's compensation plan differs from the expectations of families bereaved by the 2010 bus hostage tragedy by "a wide gap", the relatives' representative says.

The remark came after the first meeting in three years between a Manila official and the families' representative.

"The gap is quite wide," said Democrat lawmaker James To Kun-sun, who spoke on the families' behalf with Manila councillor Bernardito Ang, who is Manila Mayor Joseph Estrada's representative, yesterday.

He called the meeting a "very frank" exchange, but said the biggest difference lay in compensation and an apology for the 10-hour hostage drama that left eight Hongkongers dead and seven injured. "Compensation isn't only about the [monetary] amount - but, of course, the amounts differ by a wide gap."

On August 23, 2010, sacked Manila policeman Rolando Mendoza opened fire on board a tour bus of Hongkongers in the Philippine capital's Rizal Park.

To said he was to meet some families last night to see if they would make any concessions by tomorrow, before Ang was to leave the city. If both sides failed to budge, further meetings were unlikely to be arranged, he said.

The talk delved deeper into issues compared to one Ang held with Hong Kong government officials, To said. "[Ang] explained … their difficulties and limitations … We agreed to disagree."

Ang did not meet the media after the session. Local media had cited Ang on Friday as proposing compensation of US$1 million (HK$7.8 million) to be paid by the city government and ethnic Chinese businesspeople in the Philippines. But Manila vice-mayor Isko Moreno earlier said the city government planned to raise up to HK$20 million from ethnic Chinese in the Philippines, on the mainland and in Hong Kong.

No family members or survivors were present yesterday. "We don't want to be hurt," was what To said he told Ang in declining a face-to-face meeting.

Estrada, who will visit Beijing and Hong Kong next month, is expected to deliver a long-awaited apology.

Legislative Council chairman Jasper Tsang Yok-sing has urged Franklin Drilon and Feliciano Belmonte, respectively Senate President and Speaker of the House of Representatives of the Philippines, to "call on the Philippine government to respond positively" to the requests of the survivors and bereaved families.




This article is now closed to comments

Compensation should be calculated according to established principles of common law negligence according to the loss suffered by each victim's dependants and estate. Dragging this out is doing nobody any good and only prolongs the emotional anguish of the survivors and their relatives.
Money compensation is never enough and can never heal what has been lost.The Philippines is a third world country and therefore cannot afford much.
Extract from news reported in August 2010
Tour members who lost their lives will be offered one million HK dollars each by the insurance company according to the highest standard, as well as a gratuity of 20,000 HK dollars by the Hong Kong government, said the representative whose family name is Wang.
As for the injured, the highest amount of insurance benefits for medical care will be one million HK dollars, said he, adding that those who suffer from post-crisis trauma and in need of psychological treatments will be considered giving 100,000 HK dollars in the next six months.
Lau Mei-sze, manager of Hong Thai, said that most of the tour members had bought insurance through the travel agency if not on their own. The group leader who informed the agency of the crisis before being killed in the bus was also covered by insurance.
How many faimiles are going to share that sum of money. I don't think it will go too far. Lets hope the hostages were insured...
At least that is a start of something which should have been done 3 years ago. I think nobody can expect agreement during a first meeting. That is what negotiations are for, to discuss and see where one can compromise to bring the gap closer.
Yes, this should have been done 3 years ago. Did bow-tie's administration do anything? I am happy to see a ray of light finally. The families must be realistic though as there must be 'give and take' from both sides for negotiations to succeed. Narrow the differences and let this be erased from the mind. May not be a Happy Halloween as yet but hopefully they will have a Merry X'mas.


SCMP.com Account