Wasting water cheaper than bigger reservoirs: Paul Chan

PUBLISHED : Monday, 09 December, 2013, 6:37am
UPDATED : Monday, 09 December, 2013, 6:37am

The cost of increasing the capacity of Hong Kong's reservoirs exceeds that of simply discharging excess water into the sea, the development minister has said as he defends accusations that the government is wasting water from overflowing reservoirs.

Expanding the reservoirs would incur substantial project and operating costs, amounting to much more than it would cost to boost water supply through current means, such as purchasing Dongjiang water, Development Secretary Paul Chan Mo-po wrote on his blog.

"Some reservoirs in Hong Kong - such as the Kowloon Reservoir and Tai Tam Reservoir - are listed as statutory heritage, where expansion is not appropriate [as the works involved might affect the structures]," he wrote.

"It is also a concern that the ecological environment at the lower course would be affected by any construction works to enlarge the reservoirs."

Because of extreme weather and heavy rainfall in recent years, many of the city's reservoirs are overflowing, meaning excess water must be discharged into the sea, local media reported.

The reports said the cost of water released over the past eight years amounted to as much as HK$1.1 billion of public money.

But Chan said the government had put a great deal of effort into controlling water supply, especially in the rainy seasons.

"Flooding can rarely be seen at our two largest reservoirs, High Island Reservoir and Plover Cove Reservoir," the development minister wrote.

In 2006, the Water Supply Agreement was revised, with Guangdong province to provide Hong Kong with a more "flexible" supply of water from the Dongjiang.

The new agreement allowed for less water to be withdrawn when the city's reservoirs were full and for more water to be taken in times of drought, with the annual payment for the water remaining the same.

Under the new agreement, the total volume of reservoir water that was discharged into the sea dropped 71 per cent, from 10.1 billion square metres in 2005 to 29 million square metres last year, Chan said.