• Sat
  • Dec 20, 2014
  • Updated: 6:34am
NewsHong Kong

'No need to be so stupid': Macau academic cautions Hong Kong against importing labour

Macau academic says Hong Kong should look at problems imported workers have caused there before launching any such scheme of its own

PUBLISHED : Monday, 23 December, 2013, 12:21pm
UPDATED : Thursday, 26 December, 2013, 7:13am


  • Yes: 39%
  • No: 61%
26 Dec 2013
  • Yes
  • No
Total number of votes recorded: 277

Hong Kong should closely study the problems imported labour have brought to Macau before looking elsewhere to boost its workforce, an academic in the former Portuguese colony says.

Alex Choi Hang-keung, assistant professor of social science at the University of Macau, said imports of labour since the 1980s had sparked inflation and lay behind the government's decision to give residents large handouts each year.

But Tsui Wai-kwan, a well-known businessman and lawmaker, dismissed Choi's remarks and said Asia's answer to Las Vegas would not be enjoying its present boom without imported workers.

Labour imports are a hot topic in Hong Kong after the government suggested bringing in more workers when it launched a consultation on population policy in October.

"The importation will intensify the social problems in Hong Kong and the cultural conflicts between Hongkongers and mainlanders," Choi said. "I see no need for Hong Kong to do something so stupid."

Chief Secretary Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor pointed out when launching the four-month consultation in October that imported, low-skilled workers made up just 0.1 per cent of the total workforce, as against 26 per cent in Macau and 28 per cent in Singapore.

According to figures from Macau's Human Resources Office, there were 54,459 low-skilled non-local workers in Macau in 2010. In October this year, the number reached 108,139, with 23,633 in the construction industry, and 14,563 in the wholesale and retail trade.

Choi said Macau started to allow labour imports in the 1980s, when its manufacturing industry was booming. But Choi said the new arrivals had hampered local workers' prospects for pay rises and promotions.

"People in Macau do not usually protest. But many people take to the streets on May 1 every year because of their anger about this labour issue," he said.

"The government has been giving away cash handouts to soothe their anger. But can you imagine what could happen if the government is not financially capable of such handouts?"

Macau announced a 9,000 pataca handout for each permanent resident this year, with 5,400 each for non-permanent residents.

Bolstered by the influx of imported workers, Macau's economy has moved so fast that inflation has become a huge problem. For example, Choi says, even academics struggle to buy a flat there.

"Hong Kong is facing enough problems already. It should not follow in Macau's footsteps."

But Tsui, a standing committee member of the Macao Chamber of Commerce, said it was wrong to say the influx of workers had brought more harm than good.

He cited government figures showing that in 2002, the unemployment rate was 6.3 per cent and the median income for the workforce was HK$4,672 a month. By last year, the unemployment rate had dropped to 2 per cent and the median income had soared to HK$11,000.

"If the importation was not allowed back then, Macau would not be as bustling as it is today," he said.

But he said Hong Kong should take a gradual approach to bringing in workers.

"If the proportion of imported workers suddenly goes up to 26 per cent, like the situation in Macau, that may affect the locals. So it should be done gradually."

Hong Kong employers can use the Supplementary Labour Scheme to hire workers from abroad. But by the end of last year, just 2,415 people had come under the scheme.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Is anybody editing the articles before they go out? Text next to Carrie Lam's picture claims "local workers made up 0.1 per cent of the work force in Hong Kong".
Writing and editorial standards have gone down ++++ in the 16 years that I have been in Hong Kong.
Inflation in Macau is not a result of the importation of labour. It is consequence of the building of ever more casinos, of the raising number of Mainland visitors and of a stronger yuan. Please don't blame foreign workers for this, prof. Choi.
You don't even detail what he was wrong about! Just because you disagree with academics doesn't mean they're incompetent ****. You place far too much faith in under-informed politicians who would benefit from more reading time before making knee-jerk decisions like you want them to do.
This professor is a pure academician and a huge pessimist. Yes he was right but only for a small part compared to what he was wrong which is a huge part. Seems like there are a lot of such academicians in HK and their reticence to make critical decisions for HK seems like it is to safe guard their positions till 2017 at the least. Yes these are hard decisions made only by hard headed leaders only.
Hong Konger's are feeling Hong Kong, because the government has failed to address serious social and economic prelims. Now the answer is to import workers? How can these people be so stupid? How about setting up government subsidized centers for teaching skills to workers or a trade?
Macau has virtually zero percent unemployment and a severe labour shortage, especially in skilled labour. Not so in Hong Kong, which currently worries about a "brain drain."
"Choi says even academics struggle to buy a flat" in Macau? Academics are low-paid civil servants-- few but mainland speculators can buy a flat here, despite draconian measures by the government "to cool the property market."
"Labour imports are a hot topic in Hong Kong after the government suggested bringing in more workers when it launched a consultation on population policy in October."
What consultation? Who did the Government consult? Not the public.
Quality, not quantity, is the road to take.
And don' forget the USA monetary policy and the peg to the USD, please, prof. Choi!


SCMP.com Account