• Tue
  • Sep 23, 2014
  • Updated: 4:31am
NewsHong Kong

Government to consider poll results on people's nomination for 2017 poll

Constitutional affairs minister says Occupy Central survey seeking a voice in nominating candidates for chief executive to be reviewed

PUBLISHED : Sunday, 12 January, 2014, 5:01am
UPDATED : Sunday, 12 January, 2014, 5:01am

The government would consider the results of a New Year's Day poll on electoral reform that was organised by pro-democracy activists, the constitutional affairs minister, Raymond Tam Chi-yuen, said yesterday.

Tam also said there was no requirement in the Basic Law for the nominating committee for the 2017 chief executive election to put forward candidates "as a whole", as Beijing officials have said.

In response to criticism from a student leader at a 10-hour session in the Legislative Council, Tam said members of the public should express their views on reform based on their understanding of the mini-constitution.

About 200 people expressed their views on electoral reform and other issues at the session.

Meanwhile, during a visit to Sha Tin, also to encourage people to air their opinions about political reform, Chief Secretary Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor, who had dismissed the New Year's Day poll as irrelevant, was criticised by a "disappointed" resident for her reluctance to listen to Occupy Central campaigners.

In the New Year's Day poll organised by the Occupy Central movement, 94 per cent of the 62,000 voters demanded that the public have a say in nominating candidates for the post of chief executive in 2017.

At the Legislative Council session, the convenor of the Civil Human Rights Front, Yeung Ching-yin, asked Tam whether the administration "was forcing people to occupy Central" by dismissing the public poll.

Tam said his bureau had "received [written submissions] recently about the results of the three questions asked in the New Year's Day poll" and that he and his bureau would "include the opinions in a [report] on public views".

"It will certainly be referred to," he said.

In response to further criticism, Tam admitted that the Basic Law did not say that the nominating committee should nominate candidates "as a whole". He added that the Basic Law stated only that the committee should put forward hopefuls "in accordance with democratic procedures". Tam also agreed with some attendees that the city's leader would be "better in keeping tabs on public opinion" if he or she is elected directly.

Occupy Central organiser Dr Chan Kin-man said he appreciated Tam's pledge to consider the organisation's poll results. "The government's previous response was outrageous … but I am not sure whether this was just Tam being pragmatic or whether it represents the government's view," he said.

In the pro-establishment camp, executive councillor Cheung Chi-kong said pan-democrats should improve their ties with the central government because their relationship with Beijing "is worse than Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's".

And in an interview with ATV's Newsline to be broadcast today, Secretary for Justice Rimsky Yuen Kwok-keung says: "The only body who has the power to nominate is the nominating committee."


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

hard times !
'In the New Year's Day poll organised by the Occupy Central movement, 94 per cent of the 62,000 voters demanded that the public have a say in nominating candidates for the post of chief executive in 2017.'---this is what a geniune universal suffrage should be: civil nomination, the right to be voted and to vote and not just the right to cast ballots on a few chosen candidates who have passed through a screening mechanism.
I was the one who told Carrie that I felt disappointed on her response to ignore and reluctance to listen to Occupy Central campaigners.
In fact, this is one of opinion from residents. Carrie should put it consider as well though it is not pro-china's opinion. Carrie should put her effort to understand why & how to comprise with them, not to ignore those negative voice.
I am fully support if she can pay her effort to streamline the gap with those Occupy Central campaigners, rather than roadshow to 'hardsell' the proposal. It doesn't help her get the desire result much.
You deserve a barrel of likes.
The government now says the time is ripe for initiating the consultation exercise without explaining why. Several months ago CY kept telling us there was ample time for consultation and refused to start it. This is what is wrong with the government. It never explains the reasons for its actions and always adopts a 'we know best and you must follow' attitude.
I can't help but feel this whole consultation exercise is nothing more than a PR process in an attempt to appease the citizens of HK. The only party who controls what will happen is Beijing so let's just drop the pretense that HK people will decide. HK voters will be given a Beijing approved slate of candidates to vote for and this will be called universal suffrage with Chinese characteristics.
hard times !
maybe this Carrie Lam is just doing a warm-up exercise before the Chief Executive Election in 2017. It is learnt that she might probably be one of the contenders/competitors in that upcoming election and she had never denied it when asked about it.
CY is throwing her under the bus by making her the point person for a meaningless public consultation exercise on universal suffrage. When the truth comes out and HK people realize they have been lied to, she will take the fall.
Her standing in the eyes of the HK public seems to have plummetted in recent times, but I guess that isn't what matters.
This disarray in government ranks is the risk they run in trying to sustain the bunch of lies that this so-called consultation process represents. If your only ideology is "make our boss in Beijing happy" and you lack a finely honed propaganda organ to keep track of all the lies you have to tell, you're bound to end up dissembling from time to time.


SCMP.com Account