• Sat
  • Dec 20, 2014
  • Updated: 7:25am
NewsHong Kong

Sai Kung adventure centre accused of building illegal structures

Residents say adventure facility is carrying out unauthorised work, but Christian non-profit group says it is only restoring ageing structure

PUBLISHED : Monday, 27 January, 2014, 10:10am
UPDATED : Tuesday, 28 January, 2014, 3:30am

The Lands Department is monitoring a development in a pristine enclave of a Sai Kung country park, following complaints from local residents who say it is unauthorised.

But the Christian non-profit group that runs the 30-year-old Tolo Adventure Centre water sports facility at the centre of the row in western Hoi Ha says it is being unjustly victimised.

Building work on what residents say is a two-storey structure in the area was spotted last November, Nicola Newbery, a long-time Hoi Ha resident and chairwoman of the Friends of Hoi Ha concern group, said.

She suspected the work involved unlawful demolition, rebuilding and expansion - a violation of planning regulations in the 8.4 hectare enclave - and she reported it to authorities.

"It's another example of a 'trash first, develop later' type of scenario," Newbery said.

The adjacent Hoi Ha Wan is categorised as a site of special scientific interest.

Newbery said work involved felling trees and shrubs around the area, and she accused the operators of not obtaining planning permission.

The outline zoning plan for Hoi Ha, finalised last year, divided the enclave into areas for village development, conservation, green belt and other uses.

The adventure centre was allotted the use of 0.03 hectares inside an area entirely designated for conservation. The zoning plan limits building heights to one storey.

The centre's vice-chairman, Kung Chi-fu, defended the development, saying they were only restoring the original structure, which was falling apart.

"The dimensions of the building are exactly the same as before and we have no intention of breaking any laws," he said. "The building will be only one-storey high when completed, but because of the cockloft, it may look like it is two-storeys high."

The centre is a non-profit youth centre that provides water-sports training, equipment and facilities to about 1,300 disenfranchised youths every year.

"I think it's unfair and groundless that they are targeting us," Kung said. "We're not trying to turn into a tourist hotspot; we are just trying to help society."

The Planning Department said no redevelopment of an existing building should result in a structure in excess of that stipulated in the draft Development Permission Area plan.

But the department added: "It is not expected that the continued use of the site as a water sports recreation centre … would have any significant adverse impact on the surrounding area."

The Sai Kung Districts Lands Office revealed work on the adventure centre's main building had been carried out in line with its footprint but without permission from the office between late last year and this month. At least two unauthorised structures were in place, prompting a warning from authorities to cease work and remove the structures.

"The Tolo Adventure Centre has agreed to demolish the unauthorised structures and submitted an application for approval for resuming the suspended building works of the main building," a spokeswoman for the district's Lands Office said.

The office said it would consider the request and continue to monitor the demolition work.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

"...the strictest of planning laws."
Is there such a concept anywhere in the New Territories? I was hiking in Sai Kung Country Park Sunday and saw yet another massive project under construction along the main road in. Looked large enough for several village houses but the site was screened off so hard to tell. A concrete mixer was pumping concrete over the hoarding so probably in the foundation stage.
Since moving to the NT, I am much more aware of the extent of damage the village house policy is causing in HK's green belts. Really a shame that uncontrolled development is permitted.
All we ask the Tolo Adventure Centre to do is to obey the Law. They submitted a plan to increase the size of their centre last year but withdrew it after there were many objections to the plan. In preparation for this application, Tolo cleared a large area of Government land around their centre - only stopped when the Government was informed and put up signs. The structure they have now built contains 5 dormitories on a second floor, which would indicate that the Centre will be providing accommodation as well as a storage and meeting room, which was the function of the original building. Is this a change of use? if so, permission is required.
About 15 years ago, the Tolo Adventure Centre concreted a large area of beach without authorisation, so that they could store their boats - this was not stopped by Government. The Tolo Adventure Centre might well be a worthy organisation but they contribute little to the village and, like everybody else, they need to obey the Law and obtain the necessary permissions before carrying out significant alterations which go far beyond "restoring" the original structure.
The Rule of Law does not presently extend to many parts of the New Territories. Until it does, organisations and individuals will continue to openly break the Law in the sure knowledge that even if they are found out, Government will do little to punish them.
See the SCMP report and comments on: ****www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1413733/stop-work-order-site-historic-hakka-terrace-pak-tam-chung.
Hoi Ha is the reponsibility of Taipo District Lands Office.


SCMP.com Account