• Sun
  • Dec 21, 2014
  • Updated: 10:10pm
NewsHong Kong

Legco voting process and aggressive police practices criticised in US human rights report on Hong Kong

Limited suffrage, cases of arbitrary arrest, and hampering of freedom of assembly listed

PUBLISHED : Friday, 28 February, 2014, 9:25am
UPDATED : Saturday, 01 March, 2014, 3:08am

The limited ability of Hong Kong citizens to change their government, cases of arbitrary arrest and aggressive police tactics were fingered as the territory's biggest human rights problems in a US State Department report.

The annual report on human rights practices did not address the question of universal suffrage in the 2017 chief executive election. But it did criticise the Hong Kong government for taking "no steps to eliminate" the functional constituency seats in the Legislative Council. Beijing was expected to criticise the report. It slammed US consul Clifford Hart last year after he called for "genuine universal suffrage".

The 2017 poll and the 2016 Legco election are currently subject to a five-month government consultation. That has raised expectations for the reform of the functional constituency system before the 2020 Legco poll, which is supposed to be conducted by universal suffrage.

The report said pan-democratic parties faced "institutional challenges" that prevented them from gaining a majority in Legco and having their candidate elected chief executive.

"The voting process ensured pro-business representatives and government allies controlled a majority," the report said of Legco. "In addition, the central government and its business supporters provided generous financial resources to parties that supported the central government's political agenda."

The document said reports of arbitrary arrests during demonstrations and "aggressive tactics hampering the freedom of assembly" had raised concern.

"Some activists also alleged that police faced no penalty for making arrests that ultimately were not prosecuted or were dismissed … allowing them to use arrest to intimidate and discredit protesters," the report said.

It also cited concerns journalists were self-censoring and that editors were deferring to the perceived business concerns of their publishers.

The report came days after an attack on Kevin Lau Chun-to, whose removal as chief editor of Ming Pao last month raised concerns about media freedom. The attack on Lau was condemned by the US and the European Union.

The report on China also contained sections on Tibet and Macau. It said people-trafficking remained a problem in Macau.

Asked about the report, a Hong Kong government spokesman said universal suffrage for the 2017 poll was the "common aspiration" of the local and central governments. He did not address the matter of functional constituencies.

"The government reiterates that Hong Kong's constitutional development under the Basic Law is its internal affair," he said. "Foreign governments should respect this principle."



For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

aggressive police practices..... coming from the USA. Whats next? Respect woman reports coming from Saudi Arabia? corruption index from Russia? world safest food index from China? etc?
sudo rm -f cy
Cue Beijing telling the US once again to "butt out of our internal affairs".
haha , yea please listen to america so you too can become a cesspool or decadent garbage run by the gay mafia
hk needs more kardashians gracing the press to make it more fair and balanced
the press in america suppresses itself due to PC based navel gazing , why would anyone on earth wish to emulate the garbage they print
They miss the point - possibly intentionally so. If the fight for an un-screened chief executive candidate is lost than universal suffrage is lost as HK is an executive-led system, not legislative. The functional constituencies mean nothing as the LegCo has little to no power. Thus, the critical fight is not for 2017, not 2020.
Let's learn from US, we shall copy their "democratic" system. Also, their reporters have not seen youtube on regarding police excessive force. I agree our police shall be like US. Firm !
Keep telling the world and you might as well believe it, disillusioned!
US criticising HK on police aggreesive practice? Funny.
Dai Muff
You fail to notice that it is on YouTube precisely because Americans do not consider it acceptable. While the 50 centers here DO consider HK police tactics acceptable, even in protest situations (which the US examples are not).


SCMP.com Account