• Fri
  • Aug 29, 2014
  • Updated: 7:04am
NewsHong Kong

From Nine Dragons to Fire Beach: Creator of alternative MTR map seeks translation help

PUBLISHED : Tuesday, 15 April, 2014, 11:26am
UPDATED : Tuesday, 15 April, 2014, 4:25pm

The creator of an alternative map of Hong Kong's MTR system, where Cantonese names are translated into their literal English versions, is looking for help with tricky translations so he can update his work.

Justin Cheuk, 20, who is studying international relations at Durham University in the UK, created the map earlier this month when it occurred to him that the origin of the names of many MTR stations were a mystery to non-Chinese speakers

It has since attracted thousands of views to Cheuk's bilingual blog that he had been using to stay in touch with friends in Hong Kong.

And now he is looking for help so he can publish an improved second edition.

“A few were quite difficult to translate. And there were a few where once I figured out what they meant, I was quite surprised,” he told the South China Morning Post.

“A lot of the English names are just transliterations based on how the Chinese words sound. But that’s quite unhelpful for someone who does not speak Chinese because they won’t know what the words mean.”

For example, Wanchai station is named as such in English because it is pronounced “waan zai” in Cantonese. But in the blogger’s alternative map, the English name for Wanchai station is “Little Bay”, while Yau Tong station is “Oil Pond” and Heng Fa Chuen is “Apricot Estate”.

Several MTR stations are named after public housing estates. Cheuk said attempts to give auspicious names to the estates resulted in names that sound awkward when translated into English, such as “Permanent Security” for Heng On station and “Utmost Peace” for Tai Woo.

Cheuk said it was especially difficult to come up with a translation for Tiu Keng Leng station, which he renamed as “Tune View Ridge” but is considering changing to “Fairview Ridge”.

He is also searching for explanations of some of the stranger station names.

“I’ve heard theories that Cantonese people made up rude names on purpose to annoy the British colonial government, but I’m not sure,” he said.

He said Tsing Yi station is a Chinese pun for “stripping off clothes” in Chinese, while the original name of University Station was Ma Liu Shui, which may have been a pun for “Horse Urine”.

Share

For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive
 
 

 

9

This article is now closed to comments

kalinachu
i was having a lot of fun reading the new MTR map haha
meoii
haha...if the new names are ever adopted, have fun asking people where Causeway Bay is~! Everyone else would be scratching their heads.
-
A foreigner saying "Gong Bay, Gong Bay, where is Gong Bay?".
First reaction would be: What?! (Is that English or Chinese?)
Second reaction: "Cheers?". (Sounds more like Mandarin). Points over to the nearest bar.
ohyeahar
I certainly wouldn’t mind if the MTR uses these names as the official names of the stations. Most of the current English names makes zero sense anyway to a non-Chinese speaker. Might as well attach some flare to the names. If anything, it’ll make them more memorable.
ianson
Fail to see how dousing names in flames would assist comprehension and memorability.
MOSNT
"Tiu Keng Leng station, which he renamed as “Tune View Ridge” but is considering changing to “Fairview Ridge”."
A friend told me that this is cleaned up version for a name referring to the Japanese executing people there-- hence the difficulty in translation.
hm03
Durhan? Is it Durham University? And if it is Durham University, it's in Durham, not London.
joannascmp
Sorry! Blame the Canadian. Fixed now. -Joanna
hm03
Nah no worries. I am a journalist too so you have my understanding. We all make mistakes!
joannascmp
:)
 
 
 
 
 

Login

SCMP.com Account

or