• Wed
  • Dec 24, 2014
  • Updated: 11:29pm
Occupy Central
NewsHong Kong

New Catholic bishops say civil disobedience OK if for common good

Newly appointed auxiliary bishops, two Catholic clergymen suggest Occupy Central could be just, while third weighs in on reform report

PUBLISHED : Sunday, 13 July, 2014, 5:21am
UPDATED : Sunday, 13 July, 2014, 11:34am

Two auxiliary bishops newly appointed by the Vatican have spoken out about the Occupy Central campaign, saying the church supports civil disobedience when it's for the common good.

A third new auxiliary bishop meanwhile said the Hong Kong Catholic diocese had come under pressure from the government to consider shutting down its outspoken Justice and Peace Commission because it has been critical of the administration.

The bishop, the Reverend Michael Yeung Ming-cheung, also weighed in on politics, saying he wanted the government to hold off on submitting to Beijing its report on a five-month public consultation on electoral reform.

The three were speaking yesterday after they were named auxiliary bishops on Friday.

The news came after Pope Francis asked Cardinal John Tong Hon to stay on as bishop of Hong Kong for another three years, even though he is nearing the retirement age of 75.

Yeung said postponing the submission of the electoral reform report would provide more time for communication.

"Lots of [people] have said that there's no rush to submit the report to the National People's Congress. So waiting could mean more time for dialogue - and more chance for progress," Yeung said.

He said Hong Kong government officials had since the handover asked him to consider closing down the Justice and Peace Commission because it had been critical of the administration - a suggestion he said he flatly rejected.

The government declined to comment on Yeung's remarks.

Yeung, 68, is vicar general of the city's diocese and considered more experienced in the church's administrative affairs than the other two new auxiliary bishops - the Reverend Stephen Lee Sang-bun, 57, and the Reverend Joseph Ha Chi-shing, 55.

Ha, who joined Cardinal Joseph Zen Ze-kiun on the July 1 pro-democracy march, had a message for anyone planning to join the Occupy Central action: be mindful to keep any disruption in proportion to the cause.

Organisers are threatening to mobilise 10,000 supporters to block main roads in Central if the government does not propose truly democratic electoral reform for the chief executive election in 2017, the first Beijing has said may be held under universal suffrage.

"The church is very clear on this," Ha said. "Civil disobedience is allowed when … the authorities - which should be acting for the common good of society according to moral principles - are not acting for the common good, or if there is an unjust law." Lee agreed with that sentiment.

Ha also shot down a comment made last Sunday by Anglican Church Archbishop the Most Reverend Dr Paul Kwong that Hongkongers should keep quiet just as "Jesus remained silent" in the face of crucifixion.

"The Bible is very thick," Ha said, adding that there was nothing wrong with expressing one's views in a lawful manner.

Yeung said the church would neither encourage nor stop Catholics from joining Occupy Central, but that it would offer help to anyone arrested.

The auxiliary bishops were appointed late last month, and will be ordained next month.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Just wonder why the Catholics would not want a say as to who can become their Parish Priest, Bishop, Archbishop, and even the Pope. Religion and Politics should NEVER mix, despite the fact there are lots of politics inside religion itself!
Is it for the common good when only about 22% of the electorate took part in Occupy Central? What about the 78% that chose not to take part? Are those catholic bishops going to ignore their rights and wishes?!!!
Only an idiot like you would speak like that. OC offered...? What did it offer? Offered you to get what you want by causing damages to the others, like the blackmailer or terrorist?
Stick to your medieval repressive religion and leave politics alone, you guys
By mixing religion into this thing, it loses all credibility.
Are these bishops elected through a one catholic one vote system?
why is anyone listening to the pedophile society? why are these guys involved in politics? dont they have some kids to groom?
"we need god to enable these judges"....how the hell do u propose to do that? u have god's cellphone number?
or are u hearing voices in your head again??
The Catholic Church is berifit of all moral high ground for obvious reasons
Just shut your mouth and get lost
What 22% are you talking about? Many votes were cast by kids not eligible to vote. Some of them submitted fake ID numbers that could not be validated. In many cases, juvenile fanatics used their siblings and grannies ID numbers to cast multiple votes. Chan Kin Man, Benny Tai and others using this inflated figure are shameless liars. But this number has been used by foreign media, NY Times, WSJ, Financial Times, The Economist etc. as representative of HKers' opinion.
These clerics speak with forked tongues. I don't share the paranoia that HK is destitute of freedom. In fact we are freer to speak our minds than all the democracies I have lived in and visited.
What is common good? What is moral? These questions are nonstarter if you begin with an irresistible urge to spite China, deliberately violate HK laws, block streets, prevent people from earning their daily bread and shutting down businesses. Remember the clearly stated purpose of the organizers is to hold HK and HKers hostage in extracting concessions from Beijing.
Of course, religious fanatics will rationalize anything. Thou shalt not kill sounds clear enough to anyone, except to fanatics who say killing is justifiable because of self defense. That's how Western democracies started most foreign wars killing millions since WW2. Violating the law is okay because they live on God's moral high ground.
Charlatans and juveniles will inherit the land in an election if the rigged referendum is any guide.



SCMP.com Account