• Tue
  • Sep 23, 2014
  • Updated: 3:24pm
NewsHong Kong

Villagers in Lantau destroy mangrove in bid to halt 'protected status' plan

Demonstrators in northern Lantau fear their rights to farm and build small houses will be restricted if area nearby gets protected status

PUBLISHED : Monday, 25 August, 2014, 5:31am
UPDATED : Monday, 25 August, 2014, 11:18am


  • Yes: 92%
  • No: 8%
25 Aug 2014
  • Yes
  • No
Total number of votes recorded: 430

Dozens of villagers in northern Lantau chopped down a mangrove near an ecologically sensitive bay yesterday to protest against a government move to zone areas on the fringes of their villages as protected land.

Excavators were brought in to raze trees, while machete- and hoe-wielding villagers chopped down shrubs on the coast of Tai Ho Wan, which is known for its oyster-rich mudflats and horseshoe crabs.

Together with the three rivers that feed it, Tai Ho Wan is now designated as a Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI), but not yet zoned as such. Statutory planning rules would ensure government departments give due consideration to conservation if the proposal was approved later this year.

But indigenous villagers of the San Heung community, which includes Pak Mong, Ngau Kwu Long and Tai Ho villages, fear their rights to farm and build small houses will be restricted if the restrictive development plans are agreed to.

"Step by step, the government has been depriving us land owners of our rightful use of land, which was originally designated for agricultural use," the community said in a declaration in which they also demanded to meet the development and environment ministers.

They blamed construction of the North Lantau Highway in the 1990s for blocking discharge from the river and flooding coastal farmland. The indigenous villagers said in their declaration that the government had "bullied" them again in 1999 with the SSSI designation.

"All we want is to return our farmland to agricultural use without any prior conditions," said Ngau Kwu Long village spokesman Lam Chu. "You can't just take away our land without our consent or compensation."

Heung Yee Kuk vice-chairman Daniel Lam Wai-keung showed up to support the villagers' protest yesterday.

Green groups were outraged at the destruction of the mangrove. "I'm furious. This is disrespectful," said Eddie Tse Sai-kit of the Save Lantau Alliance. "If they really cared for the land and wanted to farm it, then they would not do such a thing."

Tse said most of the private land in the enclave had been sold to developers in the 1990s.

"It is worth questioning whether they're really doing this for the right to build small houses," he said.

Under an interim development plan covering 230 hectares, gazetted in March, the villages' development zones are limited to 1.27 hectares, which the villagers say constrains their right to build small houses.

"It's a lie … Most villagers just want to transfer their small-house rights for a profit," said Green Sense president Roy Tam Hoi-pong. "If they wanted to farm they would have done so long ago."

The Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department said it was only illegal under the Forests and Countryside Ordinance if the trees were felled on government land.

The Planning Department said it would follow up and check to see if the villagers had breached town planning rules.


For unlimited access to:

SCMP.com SCMP Tablet Edition SCMP Mobile Edition 10-year news archive



This article is now closed to comments

Honestly, it's time to bring an end to Heung Yee **** - it's an outdated institution and serves only to protect the interest of a few. There is no justification whatsoever why the indigenous villagers should be treated any different from the rest of millions of Hongkongers, now that Hong Kong has returned to the sovereignty of China. The indigenous villager status was created to appease the villagers back in the colonial days. I'm just sick of there being a royal class of families, who have a claim of entitlement, just by virtue of their birthright.
Its times like these where we hope that Central Government can take a more assertive stance with the affairs of Hong Kong. If this happened on the Mainland, you can be sure that their new life goals will be to regrow these mangroves! Or else :)
These people need to stop breeding.
Abolish the Small House Policy: ****supporthk.org/i.php/View/430
Blackmail. These arrogant, greedy people don't want to farm, they want to get rich by fiddling the Small House Policy. The Government is reaping what it sowed by its cowardly policy of appeasing the H Y K in return for political support.
It is sad to hear and see the destruction of the mangroves. If these people call themselves 'farmers' then they know nothing about mother nature. They are no 'farmers' just gardeners growing a few crops for self-consumption, so they can hardly be called farmers. However, the word 'landowner' has a more prestigious tone. The 'ting' house system is out of date and should be abolished by law as it serves no purpose whatsoever. The government is strong in the city, yet so lacking in other areas that they are often tested to the brink of having seem to be dropping their pants with indecisions. Once again, our EPD is sleeping on these issues.
In cases such as this, restrictions on development should be implemented immediately as a punishment for deliberate damage like this and to let the villagers know that such destruction does not work in their favour.
Should lock those **** up
This is just so terrible and sad to see this wanton destruction of beautiful mangroves. All for greed and avarice. The procrastinating government need to develop some negotiating skills. The Legislators are too busy for now too tied with their obsession with Universal suffrage. They can't see the wood for the trees. ah ha there's none left!
Too late, too late




SCMP.com Account