Advertisement
Hong KongEducation

University of Hong Kong students say no to compulsory studies in mainland China in union poll

Student union poll finds most undergraduates oppose mandatory study trips - but university defends idea and says details are not finalised

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Some 1,400 students had voted in the poll by yesterday, 9 per cent of undergraduates. Some 97 per cent said HKU should not dictate where students went on study trips. Photo: Jonathan Wong
Stuart Lau

Some 97 per cent of University of Hong Kong students oppose a policy of forcing all undergraduates to go to a place specified by the university to study, a student union poll shows.

The online vote was launched after it emerged on Friday that the university was considering having all students undertake at least one mainland and one overseas learning programme. The idea was raised by HKU vice-president Professor Ian Holliday at a dinner on Friday. Students present quoted him as saying: "If you don't agree with the policy, then please don't come to HKU."

Holliday yesterday apologised for that remark and said more consultation would take place on details such as whether the trips would be compulsory.

Advertisement

Some 1,400 students had voted in the poll by yesterday, 9 per cent of undergraduates. Some 97 per cent said HKU should not dictate where students went on study trips. Just 22 per cent expressed an interest in going to the mainland, while 96 per cent regarded "overseas countries other than China" as attractive.

"When fellow students heard they were to go to the mainland … their reaction was very big," union president Billy Fung Jing-en said yesterday after talks between the union and Holliday.

Advertisement
Professor Ian Holliday rejected union criticism of a lack of transparency in the way the idea was put forward in a submission to the University Grants Committee.
Professor Ian Holliday rejected union criticism of a lack of transparency in the way the idea was put forward in a submission to the University Grants Committee.
Fung said an international university like HKU should not single out mainland China as a destination for study trips.

"A single category of 'international' is enough," he said. But Holliday had a different view, citing his experience of organising trips to far-flung parts of the nation in his previous role as dean of social sciences.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x