Legislative Council elections 2016

Why Hong Kong’s election newcomers need to stir young people to get out and vote

Radicals looking to grab Legco seats face a steep battle as it’s conservative older people who traditionally cast their ballots in greater numbers

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 25 August, 2016, 8:01am
UPDATED : Thursday, 25 August, 2016, 9:55am

The record number of young candidates running for seats in the Legislative Council elections on September 4 are likely to face an uphill battle unless they can mobilise young voters, who consistently turned out in low numbers at previous polls.

According to a Post study of election turnout from 2008 to 2015, those aged 18 to 35 were the least active voters, with a turnout rate constantly below Hong Kong’s overall average.

Although the turnout among young voters in the district council elections last November surged from 29.9 per cent in 2011 to 36.6 per cent in the wake of the Occupy movement, they still trailed far behind the 53.1 per cent turnout for those aged 61 or above.

The turnout rate of these elderly voters was above average in both the 2008 and 2012 Legco polls, as well as the district council elections in 2011 and 2015.

In one extreme case, almost 62 per cent of voters aged 66 to 70 cast their ballots in the last Legco polls, when the average turnout was 55.2 per cent. Only 42.3 per cent of voters aged between 18 and 20 cast their ballots that year.

Elderly electors are traditionally regarded as having a pro-establishment inclination. Last year the Post revealed how pro-Beijing parties helped residents of elderly homes to register as voters, subsequently ferried them to polling stations and allegedly told them who to vote for.

Political scientist Ivan Choy Chi-keung of Chinese University said young people were never core voters in Hong Kong, but he believed things might start to change this year.

He pointed to the New Territories East Legco by-election in February, where rising pro-independence leader Edward Leung Tin-kei, of Hong Kong Indigenous, raised eyebrows by securing more than 15 per cent of votes.

Arrival of young blood in Legco set to transform Hong Kong politics

In that historic poll, the turnout of those aged below 40 surged drastically and contributed to one-third of total ballot papers.

“It might be too early to generalise what happened in New Territories East to the whole of Hong Kong as after all the constituency has the largest pool of young voters while Leung also has his own charisma,” Choy said.

“But with the emergence of new groups which advocate fresh agendas such as localism and self-determination, perhaps the young voters this year will be more motivated to cast their ballots.”

But Leung will not run next month. He is one of six young radicals who had their nominations invalidated by the Electoral Affairs Commission because of their advocacy of independence for Hong Kong.

While Choy said the pro-establishment camp might not have tried its best to mobilise voters in the by-election, he believed the bloc would step up its effort this time amid a sense of crisis.

Hongkongers’ post-1997 identity crisis at the heart of youthful mistrust of government

According to the latest electoral roll, almost 47 per cent of the city’s voters were 36 to 60 years old, while young voters aged below 35 and elderly voters aged above 60 made up 24 per cent and 29.3 per cent of the pie respectively.

A large number of people were driven to register as voters following the pro-democracy sit-ins in 2014, but that surge was seen across the age spectrum and not limited to the young generation, who have often described the civil disobedience movement as their “political awakening”.

Meanwhile, the pan-democratic camp faces another challenge resulting from the steady influx of mainland Chinese immigrants allowed into Hong Kong under the one-way permit scheme, which allows 150 of them to settle in the city each day.

In a recent study in an academic journal, Hong Kong political scientists Stan Wong Hok-wui, Ma Ngok and Lam Wai-man used data analysis to prove a long-held assumption – that these immigrants tended to offer staunch support for the government.

“People who decide to move to an undemocratic place tend to be more tolerant towards an autocratic regime,” Ma explained.

The study found that two-thirds of pan-democratic supporters were Hong Kong natives, while 56 per cent of pro-Beijing backers were immigrants.

The researchers argued that the establishment could take advantage of the influx of mainland Chinese immigrants to counter-balance the rising democratisation demands of local people.

Click here for a full list of Legco 2016 candidates

Additional reporting by Joyce Ng