Advertisement
World

Moscow denounces US rights abuses in cold-war style

Tone and spirit of Russian foreign ministry's diatribe about human rights abuses in America revives memories of Soviet-era propaganda

2-MIN READ2-MIN
Moscow's references to secret US prisons and detentions without charge are "out of context," according to one analyst. Photo: Bloomberg

Prisoners detained without charges. Prisons operating outside the legal system. Limits on free speech and the internet. Voters prevented from casting their ballots. Sanctioned kidnappings. Witch hunts and torture. It's all part of life, says the Russian government - in the United States.

The Russian Foreign Ministry has issued a hefty 56-page report in Russian and English titled On the human rights situation in the United States.

The report, distributed at hearings held by the Foreign Relations Committee of the Russia's lower house of parliament, was the first such full examination of the US human rights record issued by Moscow since the fall of communism in 1991. In tone, vocabulary and spirit, it was reminiscent of the cold-war-era propaganda counterattacks launched by the Soviet Union on its rival.

Advertisement
"I wouldn't be surprised it should feel like travelling back to the USSR," said young journalist Olga Kuzmenkova of the online publication gazeta.ru as she emerged from parliament. "I can't believe what I have just heard. I can't believe my country is moving back in time so fast."

The tone was set by committee chairman Alexei Pushkov, who said he and his colleagues did not agree "that human rights topics should remain the prerogative of states that call themselves traditional democracies."

Advertisement

"Around these violations an information vacuum has been created and ... as a result we see a distorted picture of all but an exclusive right of the United States to deal with that topic," Pushkov told the sparse audience of lawmakers, speakers, journalists and a group of political science students invited by the organisers.

"On a whole number of issues, I think Russia has a greater moral right to raise questions than our American partners as we don't have secret prisons, we do not kidnap people, we haven't had any serious scandals connected with violating international law."

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x