French leader Hollande backs moves to ban 'anti-Semitic' comedian

Newspaper also charges that the performer did not pay taxes

PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 08 January, 2014, 6:37pm
UPDATED : Wednesday, 08 January, 2014, 6:46pm

President Francois Hollande has backed attempts to ban controversial French comedian Dieudonne as a furore intensified over his sketches that have been widely condemned as anti-Semitic.

The move came as Dieudonne asked a court to reverse a ban on the show that kicks off his nationwide tour, his lawyer said on Wednesday.

The 47-year-old was due to start his tour on Thursday in the western city of Nantes, but as in several other cities around France, authorities there banned his performance after Interior Minister Manuel Valls, backed by Hollande, gave local officials the go-ahead to do so.

Hollande urged local officials to apply an interior ministry circular authorising city mayors or police chiefs to cancel performances of the comic, Dieudonne M’Bala M’Bala, on public order grounds.

Dieudonne’s material has been viewed as anti-Semitic for years, but he gained greater prominence in recent months as a result of the Internet-driven success of the “quenelle”, his trademark straight arm gesture which some have described as a reverse Nazi salute.

You can’t convict someone in advance, we live by the rule of law
Olivier Mayor, local official

A recent joke about gas chambers, secretly filmed at one of his shows, was the last straw for Valls who announced his intention to ban his performances.

Jacques Verdier, one of Dieudonne’s lawyers, told AFP he had filed an application to a court in Nantes asking that the ban be overturned before Thursday’s show in an emergency legal procedure. A hearing has been set for Thursday morning.

A French newspaper added to the pressure on the outspoken Dieudonne, reporting that he owes tax authorities more than 800,000 euros (HK$845,000) and is being investigated for suspected money laundering.

Several cities and towns, among them Nantes and Bordeaux, have declared prohibitions on shows the comedian, who goes by his first name, was to have staged. Officials said there was a risk of violent clashes between fans and protesters.

Police in Paris are also “seriously considering” banning an upcoming show in the capital, an informed source said.

Hollande said the interior ministry instructions were to “ensure that no one can use a performance for the goals of provocation and the promotion of overtly anti-Semitic theories”, without specifically mentioning Dieudonne.

But the bans are expected to face legal challenges on freedom of speech grounds.

Dieudonne’s lawyer Jacques Verdier said his client would “act immediately” against any performance ban.

Local official Olivier Mayor said Dieudonne could not be banned there because of a precedent set when Geneva tried to ban him several years ago with a decision that was overturned by a judge. “You can’t convict someone in advance, we live by the rule of law,” Mayor said.

Opponents fear bans will only fuel his popularity with his target audience and enhance his opportunities to cash in on the notoriety.

Sinister trend

Dieudonne, 47, is the son of a father from Cameroon and a white French mother. He has been performing anti-Semitic material for years but gained greater prominence in recent months as a result of the internet-driven success of the “quenelle”, his trademark straight arm gesture which some have described as a reverse Nazi salute.

Footballer Nicolas Anelka, a former member of France’s national team, stirred up a row by performing the gesture during a goal celebration for his English club West Brom last month.

Defenders of the comic say the gesture is simply a coded “up yours” directed at the French establishment and thousands of ordinary French people have used it without being aware of any racist overtones.

The gesture has taken on sinister connotations, however, with the publication of pictures of Dieudonne fans performing quenelles outside synagogues, at a holocaust museum and in front of the school in Toulouse where in 2012 an Islamist gunman killed a rabbi and three Jewish children.

Dieudonne’s popularity -- more than 5,000 tickets have been sold for the opening night of his tour -- has exacerbated concern over a perceived resurgence of anti-Semitism in France under the guise of a brand of anti-Zionism.

Coming in the wake of a series of incidents last year in which the country’s most prominent black politician, Justice Minister Christiane Taubira, was subjected to monkey taunts, concerns have risen that overt racism is becoming dangerously acceptable in France.

The trend has been linked by some to the rising electoral popularity of the anti-immigration, anti-EU National Front (FN), founded by Jean-Marie Le Pen, who is the godfather to one of Dieudonne’s children.

Le Pen’s daughter, Marine, who succeeded him as party leader, says she is as shocked as anyone else by the comic’s anti-Semitism, but believes the government is wrong to try and ban him.

She added that she believed there was a sort of “personal vendetta” against him by Interior Minister Manuel Valls.

Le Monde daily has reported that public prosecutors in the city of Chartres, southwest of Paris, launched the money laundering probe in February last year over suspicions the comedian was illegally sending money to Cameroon.

The paper said the comic “owes tax authorities 887,135 euros”, but did not give a source.

The French finance ministry’s anti-money laundering department Tracfin would not confirm or deny the report.