Red wine antioxidant resveratol no magic pill for health, study finds
Antioxidant resveratrol doesn't help people on fatty diets avoid cancer or heart disease, study of elderly Tuscan villagers affirms
US researchers may have found a flaw with the "French paradox", or the notion that people who drink red wine can somehow avoid the pitfalls of a high-fat diet.
A study has found that resveratrol - one of the highly touted antioxidants in red wine - does not help people live longer.
Nor does it help people avoid cancer or heart disease, according to the research published in JAMA Internal Medicine.
"This study suggests that dietary resveratrol from Western diets in community-dwelling older adults does not have a substantial influence on inflammation, cardiovascular disease, cancer, or longevity," said the research, led by Richard Semba of the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine.
Research on animals has suggested resveratrol, a polyphenol also found in some Asiatic plant roots as well as peanuts and berries, may wield beneficial health effects.
Although not proven in human studies, those findings had contributed to a US$30 million-a- year market for resveratrol supplements in the United States alone, researchers said.
The latest study was based on measures of resveratrol levels in the urine of nearly 800 people in two small villages in Tuscany, Italy. They were chosen because they had wine as their main source of resveratrol and did not take supplements.
Researchers measured their urine for signs of resveratrol, to see if the amounts they were getting through their diet would contribute to improved health.
The subjects were 65 or older when they joined the study in 1998. In the next nine years, 34 per cent died, and researchers could find no correlation between early death and resveratrol levels. Nor could they find any significant links between resveratrol and the development of cancer or heart disease.
"These data are consistent with other studies that found that the method of alcohol consumption had no effect on outcome or if there is a benefit to red wine it does not appear to be mediated by resveratrol specifically," said Blase Carabello, chair of cardiology at Mount Sinai Beth Israel.
Indeed, some previous research has suggested resveratrol may not be the cure-all some have hoped, including studies that have shown no impact on blood pressure, metabolism or lipid levels.
"The only way to be certain would be through a randomised trial but the current data lend little support for performing such a trial," added Carabello, who was not involved in the study.
According to Robert Graham, an internist at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York, the "French paradox" is still a mystery.
"This study is a great example of how difficult it is to examine the role of 'the magic bullet' for health and longevity, in this case resveratrol," said Graham, who was not part of the research.
Harvard University researcher David Sinclair, who has pioneered much of the research on resveratrol, said the Chianti study certainly cast doubt on a central tenet of the "French paradox" - the surmise that it is the resveratrol in red wine consumed by the French that has kept cardiovascular disease relatively low in a country where saturated fat is plentifully consumed.
But the study does not extinguish hopes that "resveratrol or more potent molecules like it will make effective drugs", said Sinclair.
"We're becoming more aware that the effects of resveratrol are pretty much context dependent: If you have a challenge or disease, resveratrol seems to have a positive effect," said researcher Rafael deCabo. But it may not be the "primary prevention drug" that many health-conscious Americans had hoped.
Additional reporting by McClatchy-Tribune