‘Eliminate the odour’: newspaper editorials call on Clinton to shutter charitable foundation

PUBLISHED : Thursday, 25 August, 2016, 10:29am
UPDATED : Thursday, 25 August, 2016, 10:38pm

The Clinton Foundation, the family philanthropy of Democratic U.S. presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, should shut down or transfer operations to another charity despite its good work to avoid perceptions of “pay-for-play,” The Washington Post and USA Today said in editorials on Wednesday.

Despite plans announced earlier this week to reorganise the Clinton Foundation if Hillary Clinton wins the November 8 election, USA Today said the global charity must close for the Democratic candidate to avoid any appearance of unethical ties.

“The only way to eliminate the odour surrounding the foundation is to wind it down and put it in mothballs, starting today, and transfer its important charitable work to another large American charity such as the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation,” the paper’s editorial board wrote.

Clinton aide’s emails show links between US State Department and former secretary’s family charity

The Gates Foundation declined to share its thoughts on the idea.

The newspaper also published an editorial by Donna Shalala, the Clinton Foundation’s president, in which she argued that the foundation helps millions of people, especially in developing countries, and so scaling down its work was not simple.

“This suggestion ignores how global philanthropy works, and the reality that there are human beings around the world who would be affected by these decisions,” Shalala wrote.

The foundation announced on Monday that it would stop accepting at least some foreign and corporate donations if Clinton wins the presidency and that her husband, former President Bill Clinton, would resign from the foundation’s board.

The Washington Post said in its editorial that these changes were insufficient and should have happened sooner, before Hillary Clinton served as secretary of state from 2009 to 2013.

“The foundation undoubtedly does worthwhile work,” the Post’s editorial board wrote. “Should Ms Clinton win, all of that work and all of the foundation’s assets should be spun off to an organisation with no ties to the first family.” The Clintons’ daughter, Chelsea Clinton, remains on the board of the charity, the full name of which is the Bill, Hillary & Chelsea Clinton Foundation.

The call from two leading US news organisations came as Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump and other members of his party have taken to calling for a special prosecutor to investigate what they say is corruption. The Clinton campaign has dismissed such calls as groundless political smears.