Escape claws: EU considers banning North American lobsters as invasive species
The European Union is a step closer to banning the importation of lobsters from the US and Canada after a scientific panel concluded Sweden had raised valid points in its request to declare the American lobster an invasive species, to the dismay of fishermen across the Atlantic.
The opinion of the European Union’s Scientific Forum on Invasive Alien Species sets in motion a broader review that also will take into account the opinions of North American officials, who’ve criticised the proposal to ban American lobsters.
The international dispute started when Sweden announced it had found 32 American lobsters in the country’s waters earlier this year and that they pose a threat to native crustaceans. It is unclear if they had escaped after being caught elsewhere, if they had been released deliberately, or had made their way into Swedish waters naturally.
Lobstermen in the US and Canada, which together export US$200 million worth of lobster to EU countries each year, had hoped to stop the proposal before it moved any further.
The congressional delegation in Maine, the nation’s lobster leader, issued a statement saying the EU’s actions represent an “unnecessary overreaction that would have devastating economic effects on the American lobster industry that supports so many Mainers and their families.”
A spokesman for the European Union stressed that the scientific panel’s conclusion is considered preliminary. The full review won’t be completed until spring at the earliest.
The expanded review will include issues raised by scientists in the United States and Canada, and it’ll also consider economic impact and means of protecting native lobsters other than an outright ban, the European Union’s executive body said Tuesday in a statement.
It’s unclear how the American lobsters ended up in Swedish waters.
Sweden’s Agency for Marine and Water Management contends the country is right to be cautious about the appearance of a foreign species. The agency also says more research is needed into the impact of cross-breeding of American and European lobsters.
But Robert S. Steneck, a University of Maine scientist, said there’s no evidence of successful reproduction resulting in new American or hybrid lobsters in Europe, possibly because of water temperatures or unsuitable nursery habitat for American lobster.
Steneck said the risk of American lobsters becoming invasive in Europe is “vanishingly small.”
“I doubt there is evidence that the American lobster can increase in abundance to the point it creates measurable harm to the ecosystem or to humans. Those are the criteria on which ‘invasive species’ are defined,” Steneck said.
The National Fisheries Institute, a US seafood trade association, also criticised the EU actions.
“You might get hit by a car crossing the street but that doesn’t mean the only way to avoid such risk is never crossing the street,” spokesman Gavin Gibbons said. “This is an attempt to supposedly introduce a zero-risk solution to an issue that numerous researchers have said is not a genuine scientific concern.”
Maine lobstermen like Arnie Gamage Jr question how the lobsters got into Swedish waters in the first place. He’s among those who believe they were illegally released.
“It seems to me that they have a problem over there with people releasing things into the ocean. It’s their problem, not our problem,” he said.