Taiwanese smartphone maker HTC has halted at least one of its four main manufacturing lines, accounting for at least a fifth of total capacity, and is outsourcing production as a sales slump puts pressure on its cash flow, according to sources with direct knowledge of the situation.
A reporter who visited an HTC factory at the company’s former headquarters in Taoyuan, about an hour’s drive from Taipei, saw loading docks shuttered and a sign on a locked lobby door that read: “Lobby is temporarily closed for use. Thank you for your co-operation.”
HTC launched its latest version of the flagship One series handsets this year but has struggled to gain traction in a market dominated by larger rivals Apple and Samsung Electronics.
The company, whose woes have been exacerbated by supply chain constraints and internal turmoil, reported its first ever quarterly loss this month and its cash flow from operations dropped to a negative US$707.27 million as of the end of June.
Despite lacklustre sales, HTC devices usually receive rave reviews, and it has in recent months expanded its range to include smaller and larger models of the One phone and hinted at further products, including a tablet and a wearable device.
HTC initially denied it was shutting down any production, in Taiwan or elsewhere, and declined to comment on whether it was in discussions to outsource production.
“HTC in not shutting down nor has plans to sell any of its factory assets,” the company said in an e-mailed response to queries. “HTC has a very strong balance sheet and will provide the latest financials in our upcoming earnings call to investors and the broader community.”
When asked about what had been seen at the factory in a telephone interview, HTC Chief Marketing Officer Ben Ho declined to give details, but said: “Like any manufacturer, we do volume planning to optimise our lines, our manufacturing and production facilities.
“Whether we are operating those facilities depends on market demand and our own expectations. When you have less demand you work with less facilities to optimise your costs. When you have demand, or bigger growth, you definitely have to activate all these facilities.”
Two of the four sources who spoke to Reuters said HTC had combined production from two lines at Taoyuan into one, which would reduce its potential capacity by about one million phones per month, out of a total capacity of around 2.5 million at the site and around 4.5 million including operations elsewhere.
Manufacturing has been halted since at least August on the line, housed in a facility called Building H, while production continued at a nearby plant known as TY5.
Most of the assembly lines in HTC’s Shanghai factory, which can produce two million phones a month, were also out of production, one of the sources said, with only a small number of phones being produced for sale inside China.
HTC was considering selling the out-of-use production lines in China and Taiwan, two of the sources said.
“HTC’s cash flow is not doing well. It has to do something soon to generate cash,” said one of the sources with direct knowledge of the manufacturing sale plan.
HTC Chief Executive Peter Chou, the driving force behind its award-winning handsets, has temporarily handed some of his duties to the company’s chairwoman in order to focus on innovation and product development, the Financial Times reported on Monday.
Shares of HTC jumped following the report, on hopes that the change of duties among the top management will help it recapture the sparkle that saw it named Device Manufacturer of the Year at the World Mobile Congress in 2011, when its stock was flying high. The company’s market value has roughly halved this year.
HTC, which positions itself as a premium brand, will contract out some manufacturing to FIH Mobile, a subsidiary of Taiwan’s Hon Hai Precision Industry, because contract manufacturers have better component supply management and cost control. It is also in talks with Compal Communications and Wistron, according to four sources.
FIH and Hon Hai declined to comment. Spokesmen for Compal Communications and Wistron could not be reached for comment. HTC also declined to comment.
One of the sources said HTC’s top management had agreed to separate the design and manufacturing businesses, which would more closely resemble Apple’s model of creating products in-house but then outsourcing to assemblers such as Hon Hai. Samsung Electronics both designs and manufacturers its smartphones.
However, sources said even if HTC splits the two operations, it would likely hold onto some of its factory capacity initially as the split-up would be a slow process and HTC might explore the possibility of making phones for others.
In a Town Hall meeting with staff on Tuesday, CEO Chou said HTC aimed to double its shares of the high-end smartphone market to 15 per cent next year.
When asked about separating out the manufacturing business, he said the company did not rule out the possibility. The comments were reported by local media and confirmed by Ho.
At the end of June, HTC’s cash position decreased to T$48.1 billion from T$55.5 billion a year earlier as cash flow turned negative. Its balance sheet also shows that bill payments increased while less money came in from customers. Receivables increased by T$7.9 billion, but accounts payable dropped T$7.8 billion.
HTC’s return on assets (ROA) – an indicator of how effectively a company uses its assets to generate earnings - is expected to turn negative this year at -0.69 per cent, the first time since 1999, according to SmartEstimates. ROA last year was 8.1 per cent.
No potential bidders for the manufacturing space have surfaced so far, in part because the global smartphone and tablet PC supply chain is facing overcapacity, the sources said. As a result, HTC is also exploring other options to generate income by using its factories, sources said.
Several analyst and media reports said HTC was in talks with Chinese peer Lenovo Group Ltd and US online retailer Amazon.com Inc. There is also speculation that Hon Hai will use HTC’s plant for its own production.
Hon Hai said there was no plan to use HTC’s production lines in Taoyuan now. Lenovo declined to comment and Amazon could not be reached for comment.