Source:
https://scmp.com/news/hong-kong/article/1496585/tsang-blamed-delay-manila-hostage-crisis-settlement
Hong Kong

Tsang blamed for delay in Manila hostage crisis settlement

Tse Chi-hang, the brother of Masa Tse Ting-chunn who died in the tragedy, said Philippine officials said "sorry" and "apology" behind closed doors. Photo: Sam Tsang

A brother of the tour guide killed in the 2010 Manila bus hijacking blamed a lack of "engagement" by the administration of former chief executive Donald Tsang Yam-kuen for the prolonged delay in Hong Kong reaching a diplomatic resolution with the Philippines.

Tse Chi-hang also confirmed that Philippine officials - who reached a deal on Wednesday with relatives of the eight Hongkongers who were killed, which included a public expression of "most sorrowful regret" - did privately apologise for Manila's handling of the incident.

Tse, whose brother Masa Tse Ting-chunn died in the tragedy, said he felt the matter could have been resolved earlier.

"During the first or second year [after the incident], the government did not engage with the negotiations with the Philippines. The [dispute] could have been resolved earlier if the government had been more proactive," Tse told RTHK.

"I've tried my best" - these were the words that Tse Chi-kin said yesterday in front of the final resting place of his brother Masa Tse Ting-chunn, who died with seven other Hongkongers in the 2010 bus hostage tragedy. He visited the Diamond Hill columbarium yesterday, after Manila's expression of its "most sorrowful regret" on Wednesday, though short of an apology, gained the acceptance of bereaved relatives. Photo: Felix Wong
"I've tried my best" - these were the words that Tse Chi-kin said yesterday in front of the final resting place of his brother Masa Tse Ting-chunn, who died with seven other Hongkongers in the 2010 bus hostage tragedy. He visited the Diamond Hill columbarium yesterday, after Manila's expression of its "most sorrowful regret" on Wednesday, though short of an apology, gained the acceptance of bereaved relatives. Photo: Felix Wong

Tsang was the chief executive at the time of the tragedy, before he was succeeded by Leung Chun-ying in mid-2012.

Tse said Jose Rene Almendras, the cabinet secretary of Philippine President Benigno Aquino, did say "sorry" to relatives, while Manila mayor Joseph Estrada delivered an apology on multiple occasions.

Almendras told reporters this week that he could not remember whether he had used the word "sorry". Tse said that was likely because Almendras had received diplomatic and legal advice not to publicly apologise.

Last year, a senior diplomat at Beijing's embassy in Manila said the Philippines was avoiding making a public apology because it might leave the country open to being sued for misconduct by the victims' families.

In Beijing, a senior official from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs told a delegation of media executives from Hong Kong that the ministry was pleased that a deal had been reached and had offered "help and guidance" to the city's government in dealing with "compensation and the legal aspect", according to Keith Kam Woon-ting, chairman of the Newspaper Society.

Meanwhile, Tse's other brother, Tse Chi-kin, yesterday visited Masa's remains in Diamond Hill columbarium for the first time since the deal with the Philippine government was reached.

Additional reporting by Adrian Wan in Beijing