Full Michael Garcia report into Qatar World Cup bid ‘corruption’ finally released by Fifa after leak
Fifa’s hand forced after long-withheld 400-page report is leaked to German tabloid newspaper Bild
Fifa on Tuesday released a long-withheld report on claims of corruption in awarding the 2022 World Cup to Qatar after more leaks deepened the controversy surrounding the vote.
World football’s governing body had previously declined to publish in full the 400-page report into awarding the 2018 World Cup to Russia and the 2022 edition to Qatar drawn up by US independent investigator Michael Garcia.
But Fifa’s hand was forced when German tabloid newspaper Bild said it had obtained the full report and released extracts on Monday, including revelations that a 10-year-old daughter of one Fifa member had received US$2 million in her bank account.
Fifa said it was already considering releasing in full Garcia’s findings prior to the latest disclosures.
“However, as the document has been illegally leaked to a German newspaper, the new chairpersons [of the committee] have requested the immediate publication of the full report ... in order to avoid the dissemination of any misleading information,” Fifa explained in a statement on its website.
“For the sake of transparency, Fifa welcomes the news that this report has now been finally published.”
Garcia had resigned as head of Fifa’s investigatory body in December 2014 in protest after Fifa released a 40-page sanitised summary of his report which he disowned, describing it as “incomplete and erroneous”.
The full report referred to an array of suspect financial dealings including the sum of US$2 million allegedly sent by a consultant for Qatar, Sandro Rosell, to the 10-year-old daughter of a Fifa official.
The payment was described by an associate as the proceeds from a real estate deal.
But Garcia concluded that “no proof exists linking Qatar and this $2 million to the daughter of executive committee member [former Brazil football chief Ricardo Teixeira]”.
Rosell is the ex-Barcelona president who is in prison under investigation for money laundering related to the sale of the Brazilian national football team’s television rights.
Garcia’s investigation also revealed one former Fifa executive committee member thanked Qatar by mail for a transfer of several hundred thousand euros just after Qatar was awarded the 2022 tournament.
The report also documents three executive members of Fifa were flown to Rio de Janeiro for a private party ahead of the vote to decide who would host the 2022 World Cup.
Qatar won the right to host the 2022 World Cup in late 2010 and the result of the vote has been the source of enormous controversy ever since.
Following Garcia’s investigation, the adjudicatory chamber of Fifa’s ethics committee noted there had been suspicious behaviour during the bidding process but not enough to call into question the decision to give Qatar the 2022 finals or Russia the 2018 tournament.
Hours before Fifa made the decision to go public former Fifa boss Sepp Blatter had denounced the report’s leaking to Bild.
Blatter, who announced Qatar as the 2022 hosts in December 2010, said: “The only comment that I can make is that there was a leak as only the ethics commission had the power to publish the Garcia report.”
He added: “I stand by the statements made at the time by Hans-Joachim Eckert, the Ethics Committee chairman, to the executive committee.
“For him the Garcia report did not contain any elements to call into question the attribution of the 2018 World Cup to Russia and 2022 to Qatar.”
Blatter, replaced as Fifa boss in 2016 by Gianni Infantino, concluded: “I’ve always pointed out and I’ll repeat it now, it was Michel Platini’s vote in favour of Qatar which influenced the executive committee’s vote whereas there was initially an agreement to award 2018 to Russia and 2022 to the United States.”
Platini, then head of European football body Uefa, attended a dinner in Paris with Nicolas Sarkozy, president of France at the time, and future Qatari ruler Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani, on November 23, nine days before the crucial vote.
But Garcia stated that “no proof had been discovered tying Mr Platini’s vote” in favour of Doha with Qatar’s subsequent investment in France, notably the purchase of Paris Saint-Germain.
Eckert was ousted along with investigator Cornel Borbely in May and the former ethics committee chairmen defended the decision not to release the report sooner.
“The decision to not publish the report so far was completely in line with the federation’s previous decisions and the applicable Fifa rules,” they said in a statement late on Tuesday.
They said the report “only is a working document” and added that in December 2014, during a Fifa Executive Committee meeting, it was decided that only Eckert “was to decide on the publication of the report as soon as all procedures, including potential appeals to the CAS [Court of Arbitration for Sport], have been closed.”