Advertisement
Trending in China
AbacusCulture

Bots or people? Pro-China disinformation campaigns make it hard to tell

Twitter’s crackdown on pro-China accounts attacking Hong Kong protesters reveals how bots and real people combine to spread disinformation

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Bots or people? Pro-China disinformation campaigns make it hard to tell
Masha Borak
This article originally appeared on ABACUS

James Albert has been a Twitter user since 2010. He’s based in the US and often shares basketball gossip, along with ads for a K-pop website. More recently, he’s been tweeting about protests in Hong Kong.

But there’s a good chance James Albert isn’t a real person.

James is just one of the 936 accounts originating from China that Twitter removed for what it said was a “coordinated state-backed operation” to sow political discord in Hong Kong. On Monday, the social network shared the list, which represents the most active portion of about 200,000 accounts sharing content against the anti-government protesters in Hong Kong.
Advertisement

Though the accounts are now gone, the list has given researchers a glimpse into the strange world of bots -- and the real people behind them.

One of the suspicious tweets singled out by Twitter. (Picture: Twitter)
One of the suspicious tweets singled out by Twitter. (Picture: Twitter)
Advertisement

Determining which of the removed accounts is run by a real person or a bot isn’t easy. In recent years, automated social media accounts have become more sophisticated. They can be created with relatively simple software that allows anyone to run hundreds or even thousands of Twitter accounts, according to Donara Barojan, head of mitigation operations at Astroscreen.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x