Approaches to displaying jaywalkers’ information differ by city. Some cities show part of the offenders’ ID numbers and names. (Picture: 时间视频 on Weibo)
Approaches to displaying jaywalkers’ information differ by city. Some cities show part of the offenders’ ID numbers and names. (Picture: 时间视频 on Weibo)

Facial recognition in China shames jaywalking child, erupting debate

Facial recognition is commonplace in China, but concerns remain about children’s privacy

Topic |   Facial recognition
Approaches to displaying jaywalkers’ information differ by city. Some cities show part of the offenders’ ID numbers and names. (Picture: 时间视频 on Weibo)
Approaches to displaying jaywalkers’ information differ by city. Some cities show part of the offenders’ ID numbers and names. (Picture: 时间视频 on Weibo)
This article originally appeared on
ABACUS

Facial recognition is so commonplace in China that using the tech to automatically catch and shame jaywalkers is pretty common. Plenty of busy intersections in China have billboards displaying photos of people who’ve jaywalked before, with the cameras snapping their faces and matching them with police databases to figure out who they are.

But some were still shocked when they saw a billboard displaying the face of a child.

People in the city of Taiyuan, about 250 miles southwest of Beijing, noticed that one intersection equipped with a facial recognition system was displaying pictures of a minor after catching the kid jaywalking. One local media report says the pictures were shown without any facial parts blurred or covered.

READ FULL ARTICLE
“Technology not on the right track… Is publicly showing people’s pictures the big-character poster of the new age?” one user
asked
on Weibo, referring to a
type of political poster
that appeared during China’s Cultural Revolution to defame “class enemies.”

But the city’s traffic police didn’t see anything wrong. They responded to Chinese media by saying that children should be treated the same as adults, whose pictures are displayed on a public screen for up to two weeks.

While some netizens voiced opposition, many social media users agreed with the police. Many Weibo comments said children shouldn’t be any different when it comes to enforcing safety.

Approaches to displaying jaywalkers’ information differ by city. Some cities show part of the offenders’ ID numbers and names. (Picture: 时间视频 on Weibo)
Approaches to displaying jaywalkers’ information differ by city. Some cities show part of the offenders’ ID numbers and names. (Picture: 时间视频 on Weibo)
“It’s good to help minors know about shame,” says one Weibo
comment
with more than 10,000 likes.
As of 2018, China has
169 million underage internet users
, and authorities have been tightening regulations to protect them against internet addiction, “harmful information” and cyberbullying. In response, tech companies have been
adding facial recognition
to games to verify users’ identities and prevent kids from overindulging.
The
internet protection regulation for minors
holds internet companies accountable for illegally collecting minors’ personal information, and
China's minor protection law
states that the personal information of minors involved with criminal offenses should not be disclosed in media or online. However, neither of these regulations mentions circumstances involving public facial recognition systems.

For many Weibo users, though, children’s privacy isn’t as important as safety.

One user
echoed the sentiments of many by asking, “Do car accidents care whether you’re underage?”
For more insights into China tech, sign up for our
tech newsletters
, subscribe to our
Inside China Tech podcast
, and download the comprehensive
2019 China Internet Report
. Also roam
China Tech City
, an award-winning interactive digital map at our sister site
Abacus
.