THE appointment of a retired judge to run the Immigration Tribunal has led to fewer cases resulting in appeals to a higher court and saved the taxpayer $20 million in Legal Aid fees, according to Security Branch officials.
But experts say the Bill of Rights could lead to more appeals against the tribunal, especially for cases where its decisions lead to families being split up.
Officials say the appointment of a retired High Court judge as administrator to the tribunal last year boosted efficiency and saved costs in processing applications for appeals.
Mr Justice Barnes was appointed as the chief adjudicator to replace Professor Nelson Chow Wing-sun, a senior lecturer at Hongkong University and the chairman of the Social Welfare Advisory Committee who had served with the tribunal for eight years.
Tribunal adjudicators ruled on 234 cases last year with only three appeals brought up for review in the High Court.
That compared with 59 of 371 rulings requiring High Court review in 1991, one of the worst years for the tribunal, which prompted the decision to appoint legally qualified personnel to lead tribunal work.