Advertisement

Q Does poor technology education hold Hong Kong back in the world?

If ignorance is bliss then Nicola Yelland's pride in not understanding everyday technology around her must make her very happy (Talkback, December 1). Granted, in a very fast-paced and ever-changing technological world, it may be impossible for everyone to have a deep understanding of how most technologies work, but at least a general understanding makes citizens perhaps a bit more curious, aware and proactive about things affecting their life.

Dr Yelland also missed one very important aspect of the recent poll about what Hong Kong people know about technology ('Can You Explain How an Electric Light Works?', C3, November 30). There were significant differences found between men and women's perception about using and understanding technology, with men being more confident. This may suggest one factor behind the historical gender imbalance regarding education and career choice.

Up until a few years ago, only boys would take such secondary school subjects as design and technology. That has changed, with girls now participating in authentic hands-on activities. With such discrimination now eliminated, perhaps in a few years girls will be just as confident about technology as boys are. Who knows, girls may also be inspired to find out more about technology and decide to be architects, engineers or scientists.

The subject of design and technology is much more than taking tests about technology. It involves the application of tools, materials and processes to solve problems. Obviously, technological theory is included in the programmes, but most often as it relates to the practical needs of students. The curriculum is also not 'mechanistic', as Dr Yelland assumes. She should visit some of the excellent programmes around Hong Kong to witness the creative and exciting activities students are working on.

Ken Volk, Hong Kong Institute of Education

As a design and technology teacher and council member of the Hong Kong Technology Education Association, my answer to this question is yes.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2-3x faster
1.1x
220 WPM
Slow
Normal
Fast
1.1x