HKEX’s London Metal Exchange names Oliver Wyman to review nickel trading chaos amid investor lawsuits

Independent review will run until December and examine issues that forced the bourse to suspend nickel trading in March
Suspension only the second time in the 145-year-old metal exchange’s history that it had cancelled trades in one of its futures contracts

Banking & finance

Chad Brayin London

Published: 6:00am, 24 Jun, 2022

Why you can trust SCMP

The London Metal Exchange (LME) has appointed consultants Oliver Wyman to conduct an independent review into the issues that triggered a chaotic period in the nickel market earlier this year and prompted lawsuits from investors.

The Hong Kong Exchanges and Clearing (HKEX)-owned bourse halted trading in nickel and cancelled thousands of trades in the early hours of March 8 as soaring prices threatened to destabilise the market. It was only the second time in the 145-year-old bourse’s history that it had cancelled trades in one of its metals.

“We look forward to considering recommendations put forward as part of the review findings, and to taking further steps to support the long-term health, efficiency and resilience of the market and its constituents,” the LME said in a statement.

The review is expected to run until December and include “extensive market engagement and data collection,” it added.

13:54

HKEX CEO Nicolas Aguzin on the future of Hong Kong’s capital market

It comes as Britain’s financial regulators are conducting their own review of LME’s handling of the unprecedented suspension in nickel trading, which was halted for more than a week and had a chaotic restart. US hedge fund Elliott Management and quantitative investing firm Jane Street Global Trading have sued the exchange in London, seeking up to £471 million in damages.

Nickel prices, alongside other commodities, rose dramatically in early March after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine stoked concerns about supply shortages. Prices surged as much as 250 per cent in just over 24 hours, squeezing dozens of short sellers including the world’s largest stainless steel producer Tsingshan Holding Group of China.

The bourse has said the nickel market had become “disorderly” in the early hours of March 8 and the decision was made to cancel trades in order “to take the market back to the last point in time at which the LME could be confident that the market was operating in an orderly way”.

However, that decision has been criticised by some traders, who have said the exchange favoured some investors over others by cancelling completed trades that day.

In addition to the two lawsuits, the Managed Funds Association, a trade body representing some of the world’s biggest hedge funds, separately filed a formal complaint with the LME over its handling of the nickel situation.

The LME has already introduced a series of measures to try to avoid similar situations in the future, including upper and lower daily price limits for contracts that require metal to be physically delivered when a futures contract expires.

LME CEO Matthew Chamberlain speaks during LME Asia Week in Wan Chai in 2018. Photo: Xiaomei Chen

In July, LME members will be required to report their over-the-counter (OTC) positions on a weekly basis for those metals, including contracts for aluminium, copper, nickel, tin and zinc.

LME’s chief executive officer Matthew Chamberlain has pointed to the lack of transparency in off-exchange positions as one reason the bourse struggled to identify and manage the situation.

However, the industry has not necessarily embraced the OTC reporting requirements, with several respondents indicating in a consultation that they would prefer the LME wait until regulatory reviews of the situation have concluded before adopting the new measures.

Post