Wall Street pushes back on US threats to delist Chinese firms from American exchanges, calling legislation a ‘blunt tool’
- During a panel hosted by the SEC, executives of Vanguard, NYSE and Nasdaq questioned a bill under consideration that could push Chinese businesses out of American stock markets
- “Legislation is a blunt tool. The government already has a number of tools to address this,” said the NYSE’s global chief legal and regulatory officer John Zecca
Vanguard Group, the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq are pushing back on an escalating risk to their bottom lines: threats from Capitol Hill and the Trump administration to dramatically curtail US investments in Chinese companies.
During a Thursday panel discussion hosted by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the firms’ executives questioned a bill under consideration on Capitol Hill that could lead to Alibaba Group Holding, Baidu and other Chinese businesses getting kicked out of American stock markets. The intent of the legislation is to force China to comply with US accounting rules. But among the concerns raised was that it might just prompt companies to relocate to markets with less regulatory oversight.
Vanguard is among giant money managers whose mutual funds invest in Chinese businesses listed on US exchanges, while NYSE and Nasdaq make millions of dollars in fees by allowing Chinese shares to be traded on their platforms.
John Tuttle, chief commercial officer for NYSE Group, said the exchange would support adding an indicator to company tickers to ensure investors are aware of risks associated with firms whose audits aren’t inspected by the PCAOB. But he warned that the proposed legislation could backfire.
“We don’t disagree with it philosophically,” Tuttle said. “However, some of the tactics - about how they want to get the results they want to get - we don’t necessarily agree with that.”
While he was careful to say that Nasdaq wasn’t opposing the pending bill, John Zecca, the exchange operator’s global chief legal and regulatory officer, was also critical.
“Legislation is a very blunt tool,” he said. “The government already has a number of tools to address this.”
The issue of Chinese stock listings has attracted the attention of President Donald Trump, who has ratcheted up his attacks on China over the coronavirus pandemic and as friction mounts due to Beijing’s recent moves that chip away at Hong Kong’s political freedoms.
SEC Chairman Jay Clayton has said he supports the legislation because denying access to PCAOB examiners creates an “unlevel playing field” for US investors. Clayton, in remarks prepared for Thursday’s event, said he expected the panellists’ comments to inform recommendations that regulators are preparing for Trump.
The long-standing requirement that all companies that trade on US exchanges submit their audits for PCAOB inspections was implemented in the wake of Enron’s 2001 accounting scandal. There are more than 200 Chinese corporations that have been allowed to sell shares in the US without complying, according to the PCAOB. Their market capitalisation is roughly US$1.8 trillion, with Alibaba making up about one-third of the total.