Advertisement
Advertisement
Stocks
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
US investors will have to adjust their asset allocation to avoid trading or owning 35 blacklisted Chinese companies when a ban takes effect from January 11, 2021. Photo: AP Photo

Trump’s ban spoils year-end party as stock index rejigs put China Mobile, CNOOC in line of fire

  • Index compilers are reconstituting their stock gauges before a ban on US investors kicks in next year, with passive funds certain to mirror them
  • Removing big guns like CNOOC, China Mobile and affiliated units from benchmarks would cause greater concerns to investors: Ample Capital
Stocks
China’s stock market should end the year with a bang after a scintillating rebound from the pandemic-driven sell-off in March. Like the local economy, its key benchmarks have outpaced those in several developed equity markets, and access to foreign investors has never been wider.
Instead, near-term optimism has waned with controversies likely to greet the new year. Global index compilers are loosening their embrace of companies deemed to have ties to blacklisted Communist Chinese military. US mutual funds with US$4.3 trillion of assets dedicated to index-based investing are certain to mirror the move to minimise tracking errors, when the investing ban on Americans takes effect on January 11.
The US has blacklisted 35 firms with at least 3 trillion yuan (US$458 billion) of market value in a US$10 trillion domestic market. Where represented, they account for 2.97 per cent, 1.9 per cent and 2.01 per cent weight in A-share indices compiled by MSCI Inc, FTSE Russell and S&P Dow Jones Indices. There is still confusion if the ban includes their affiliated constituents.
“The rebalancing act is not at its most disruptive just yet,” said Alex Wong, director of asset management at Ample Capital in Hong Kong. “The current gesture is that they are removing those companies that are not too significant from the list. When they start throwing CNOOC and China Mobile out, then we should be more concerned.”

The blacklisting is a party-pooper to an otherwise solid market run. The CSI 300 Index, which tracks the biggest firms on Shanghai and Shenzhen exchanges, has risen 19.4 per cent this year, outpacing major gauges in the US, Europe and Japan. Successive quarterly gains since March 31, at a cumulative 32.6 per cent, mean Chinese stocks are entering 2021 with the strongest tailwind since June 2015.

“A-share sentiment will likely stay rangebound for the rest of the year,” Morgan Stanley strategists said in a December 10 report showing a drop in its proprietary investor sentiment index. Near term, investors should pay attention to policy-tightening messages and potential escalation in US-China tension like the blacklisting event, they wrote.

So far, FTSE Russell and S&P DJI have announced steps to axe eight to 10 affected companies from December 21. MSCI Inc, which has been adding A shares to its emerging-market indices since 2018, will announce its decision soon, it said by email on December 11.

“We are looking at this issue very closely,” said David Wong, a senior investment strategist in Hong Kong at AllianceBernstein, the US money manager with US$631 billion of assets globally. “We have to assume that these things continue for now, but we do find that there are many interpretations on how to look at such restrictions.”

Among the blacklisted firms (and their units), 25 are publicly traded in China, Hong Kong or the US. The largest is Hong Kong-listed China Mobile, which operates the world’s largest network with 947 million subscribers, at HK$907 billion (US$117 billion) in capitalisation.

State-controlled oil explorer CNOOC (HK$310 billion), telecoms operator China Unicom (HK$132 billion), chip maker Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corp (HK$267 billion) and surveillance-camera maker Hangzhou Hikvision (416 billion yuan) are some of the larger ones.

China eases rules, widens US$222 billion inbound path, offering the yuan as safe haven

The blacklist will force global investors with an eye on Chinese assets to adapt to the volatile US-China relations. The latest round of recalibration is the second major upheaval this year. The first, triggered by the Covid-19 pandemic, was so disruptive it forced S&P DJI to postpone its scheduled March rebalancing.

The largest companies have emerged from the pandemic stronger than others, increasing concentration risk in the market and indices. As growth stock outperformed the value segment, the transformation in the economy and investment universe will extend to index construction, according to Parametric, a unit of Eaton Vance Corp.

Two trends are likely to emerge, according to China Renaissance Securities. Blacklisted Chinese state-owned companies stand to lose out to their domestic private technology companies within a country index, or to rival companies in other markets within regional or global indices.

“The lists are mostly made up of industrial state-owned companies, making them the most vulnerable,” said Bruce Pang, head of macro and strategy research in Hong Kong. “It will be positive for other emerging markets stocks, because global funds could reallocate their investment in China to other markets, while also hedging against the political risk.”

China Renaissance offers a list of 17 Chinese companies for potential inclusion in A share indices, whose stocks have gained 61 per cent on average from the depth of the market sell-off in late March to December 6, according to calculations by the Post.

Chinese companies with military ties included in major global securities indices, State Department says

Many companies identified by the US Department of State, including those banned under Trump’s executive order and other entity lists, are represented in major global stock or bond indices. One interpretation may be that the US pressure on larger companies like China Mobile, China Unicom and CNOOC may increase.

Still, index compilers have continued to add other non-controversial stocks to their indices at the same time, Pang noted. JD Health, a unit of e-commerce group JD.com, was added to FTSE Russell Hong Kong Index, as well as MSCI Standard Index and Large Cap Index soon after its debut last week.

All told, China is too big to ignore or exclude. The country now accounts for 48 per cent of MSCI Asia Pacific ex-Japan by index weight, and over 58 per cent of its risk, according to Credit Suisse strategists. Until Trump vacates the White House, speed bumps and headwinds will prevail.

“The market’s reaction is negative, but investors are not too concerned just yet,” said Wong of Ample Capital. “People won’t decide not to invest in China, because China is the only place in the world with relatively good economic growth.”

 

Post