-
Advertisement
Opinion

Hong Kong’s restless youth look to the future for change, rather than seeking to destroy the colonial past

Andrew Collinson says those involved in mass protests such as the Occupy movement are firmly focused on moving forwards, instead of campaigning to remove statues of those blamed for past wrongs, as student movements in other cities have done

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Rows of handmade paper umbrellas, a symbol of the Occupy Central civil disobedience campaign in 2014, hang at the protest site in Admiralty. Photo: EPA
Andrew Collinson

Dour-faced and clutching an ornate sceptre, Hong Kong’s former imperial Queen sits impervious to the elements in Victoria Park, Causeway Bay. In the Zoological and Botanical Gardens in Admiralty, King George VI stands proud, while Sir Thomas Jackson – one of the original architects behind Hong Kong’s banking system – casts a lengthy shadow in Statue Square. Aside from a few mutterings about replacing the last remaining colonial-era postboxes bearing the crown insignia, few of the wilder ideas to decolonise Hong Kong – including a proposal to replace British street names with the names of lauded Chinese figures – have come to pass. But with a fervent anti-colonialist zeal having swept through university campuses in South Africa, the US and England’s Oxford University, is it inevitable that a campaign to remove Hong Kong’s colonial statues will erupt?

A statue of British businessman Cecil Rhodes stands on the facade of Oriel College in Oxford. A fervent anti-colonialist zeal has swept through university campuses in South Africa, the US and Oxford University. Photo: AFP
A statue of British businessman Cecil Rhodes stands on the facade of Oriel College in Oxford. A fervent anti-colonialist zeal has swept through university campuses in South Africa, the US and Oxford University. Photo: AFP
Relations between the pro-Beijing and pro-democracy camps are rancorous, the gap between Hong Kong’s richest and poorest is growing, and China’s economic outlook is shaky. Yet in spite of a febrile political climate where fish balls are a catalyst for violent clashes with police, Hong Kong’s colonial statues continue to stand, unopposed.

History partly explains why: the last time historic statues were moved or altered in significant numbers was during the Japanese occupation. Queen Victoria was transported to Japan, but was returned and restored in 1952. Others, including governor William Des Voeux, were less fortunate, disappearing entirely and not replaced. Antipathy towards the darkest chapter in Hong Kong’s history shapes today’s ambivalence to changing the status quo.

Advertisement

But there’s a further reason why the statues are still standing: Hong Kong’s forward-looking and politically mature millennials. Mature isn’t a word typically bandied around when discussing Hong Kong’s teens and young adults, but consider the Occupy protesters: whether you agreed with their objectives or not, they shared a goal to change the legislative direction of Hong Kong. They were not interested in looking backwards or squabbling over the appropriateness of colonial relics in public places. Their focus was explicitly on the future, not the past.

READ MORE: Hong Kong’s young: Let’s start being serious – not vacuous – about the future

Musicians gathered at Tai Wai MTR station last October to protest against a ban on large musical instruments on the train. Photo: Sam Tsang
Musicians gathered at Tai Wai MTR station last October to protest against a ban on large musical instruments on the train. Photo: Sam Tsang

READ MORE: A year after Occupy Central, are Hong Kong’s young people being heard?

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x