Advertisement
Opinion

Post-war Japan should look back with gratitude and slam the door on wrongs embodied in Yasukuni

Jean-Pierre Lehmann says Shinzo Abe and other leading politicians must realise that visits to the shrine honouring Japan’s war dead revive old wounds and incite fear of a revival of militarism

Reading Time:5 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Jean-Pierre Lehmann says Shinzo Abe and other leading politicians must realise that visits to the shrine honouring Japan’s war dead revive old wounds and incite fear of a revival of militarism
Jean-Pierre Lehmann
Shinzo Abe and many other leading Japanese conservative politicians have expressed a strong desire to revise the post-war constitution, in particular Article 9, according to which Japan forever renounces the sovereign right to go to war. Illustration: Craig Stephens
Shinzo Abe and many other leading Japanese conservative politicians have expressed a strong desire to revise the post-war constitution, in particular Article 9, according to which Japan forever renounces the sovereign right to go to war. Illustration: Craig Stephens
This month, post-second-world-war Japan and I celebrate our 71st anniversary. For much of these 71 years, our existences have been quite intertwined.

I first went to Tokyo in 1950. I have childhood recollections of the intense poverty, the begging by wounded former soldiers, the “pom-pom” girls and the Occupation forces. I left Tokyo in 1959, but returned frequently in the ensuing decades.

Japanese bow and kneel in the direction of the Imperial Palace in Tokyo, as Emperor Hirohito announces on radio Japan’s defeat in the second world war. Photo: AP
Japanese bow and kneel in the direction of the Imperial Palace in Tokyo, as Emperor Hirohito announces on radio Japan’s defeat in the second world war. Photo: AP
In the 1960s, I witnessed the 1964 Tokyo Olympics, the economic boom that was termed a “miracle”, but that also included a cultural boom, notably in cinema and literature. Doing my doctorate on 19th century Japanese economic history, I had the privilege of having the great scholar and humanist Masao Maruyama as mentor. He had a great influence on me. He had been a rare courageous opponent to Japanese militarism, fascism and imperialism in the 1930s and 1940s; he occasionally recounted stories of being arrested, interrogated and tortured by the Kempeitai (Japan’s equivalent of the Gestapo). He died 20 years ago, also this month.
The country that most benefited from the Allied victory was Japan

Then, in the 1970s, when I was twice (1974 and 1977) visiting professor at Tôhoku University in Sendai, I was able to witness Japan valiantly overcoming the “Nixon shocks”. This was when then US president Richard Nixon unilaterally imposed tariff hikes on Japanese textile imports, and, more critically, took the dollar off the gold standard, sparking a dramatic rise in the value of the yen; Japan’s high growth in the 1960s had been driven by exports that benefited from a cheap yen. The Nixon shocks occurred virtually simultaneously with the oil shocks, when Opec (widely unknown and ignored until then) dramatically increased the price of oil.

Advertisement
The opening ceremony for the 18th Summer Olympic Games at the national stadium in Tokyo on October 10, 1964. Photo: AFP/Jiji Press
The opening ceremony for the 18th Summer Olympic Games at the national stadium in Tokyo on October 10, 1964. Photo: AFP/Jiji Press
I was back commuting to Tokyo throughout the 1980s when Japan’s fortunes soared. Japan was appearing to become “number one”, as it was predicted it would surpass the US in gross domestic product within a decade or two. Then US ambassador to Tokyo Mike Mansfield referred to the US-Japan relationship as the “most important bilateral relationship, bar none”. The Japanese prime minister and US president met frequently to discuss the soaring US trade imbalance and the resulting friction.

Though the Japanese initially panicked when the yen was massively revalued following the 1985 Plaza Accord, signed at the New York City hotel, they soon discovered that their global purchasing power had also increased massively. This allowed Japanese corporates and private investors to go on global spending sprees. When Emperor Hirohito died in 1989, his state funeral was the biggest in history in terms of heads of government and state in attendance. Of all the “famous” (or infamous) names associated with the second world war – Mussolini, Hitler, Stalin, Eisenhower, Churchill, de Gaulle, Tito, Chiang Kai-shek, etc, – Hirohito outlived them all. Who could possibly have believed that would be the case in August 1945?

The real reason Japan’s emperor wants to abdicate

Little was it realised at the time, but shortly after Hirohito’s death, Japan reached its zenith. The 1990s ushered in the “lost decades”, in which Japan has been wallowing economically, politically and socially since. Still, Japan has achieved a degree of peace and prosperity for which it should look back over the decades with gratitude.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x