Advertisement
Chief executive election 2017
Opinion
Yonden Lhatoo

Just SayingWhy no one really has what it takes to become Hong Kong’s next leader

Yonden Lhatoo argues that the job of the city’s next chief executive will be so demanding that all the big names being floated so far may not be up to the task

3-MIN READ3-MIN
Chief executive hopefuls (clockwise from top-left) Carrie Lam, John Tsang, Regina Ip and Woo Kwok-hing. Photo: SCMP Pictures.

One of those unforgettable moments in Hollywood history is the scene in the 1990s dark comedy, Addams Family Values, when the perpetually morose Wednesday Addams makes a supreme effort to crack a smile for everyone’s benefit at summer camp. A very young Christina Ricci plays the role to perfection, appearing to force every facial muscle into unfamiliar contractions to produce something so fraudulently sincere that it ends up terrifying everyone. It’s brilliant.

It also makes me think about Hong Kong’s looming leadership election, and the relevance of something as elementary and natural as the act of smiling in what will be a very difficult battle for hearts and minds, as clichéd as it sounds.

Take the candidacy of lawmaker and former security minister Regina Ip Lau Suk-yee, for example, as she tries to convince the city that she’s the best person for the job of chief executive. Ip has the administrative and political chops to meet the challenge, but what about the emotional quotient?

When I sat down with her for a chat last week, she came across as a sincere and deeply motivated contender, proposing a basket of practical and concrete solutions to some of Hong Kong’s most pressing problems. But when discussing the importance of popularity and the need to make an emotional connection with the public, “playing nice” took a back seat to her trademark tough talk.

Watch: Regina Ip takes questions on her leadership bid

“I don’t think we should turn an election of such importance into a smiling contest,” she said.

Advertisement
Ip is a highly divisive figure, but the person being held up as a foil to her, Chief Secretary Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor, is no better in that regard. It’s no secret that Lam is disliked among administrative officers in the civil service. Her critics see her as a cold and arrogant hardliner, and consider Ip to be a better boss, actually.

‘Clash of tai-tais’ expected in Hong Kong leadership contest

Chief Secretary Carrie Lam attends a ceremony commemorating the Nanking massacre. Photo: EPA
Chief Secretary Carrie Lam attends a ceremony commemorating the Nanking massacre. Photo: EPA
Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x