-
Advertisement
Chief executive election 2017
Opinion

Hong Kong’s next chief executive must stand up for the people

Kevin Rafferty says the office of Hong Kong’s top leader is the toughest in the world, buffeted by a myriad of conflicting interests, but hopefuls must rise to the challenge or the city risks losing its edge

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Kevin Rafferty says the office of Hong Kong’s top leader is the toughest in the world, buffeted by a myriad of conflicting interests, but hopefuls must rise to the challenge or the city risks losing its edge
Kevin Rafferty
It’s high time for Hong Kong’s leaders to tell Beijing to have more faith in the people of Hong Kong as loyal Chinese. Illustration: Craig Stephens
It’s high time for Hong Kong’s leaders to tell Beijing to have more faith in the people of Hong Kong as loyal Chinese. Illustration: Craig Stephens
There are 10 weeks to go before Hong Kong faces the most critical election in its 20 years as a special administrative region of China, when it chooses a chief executive to succeed Leung Chun-ying.

It is vital that the new leader has integrity as well as imagination, and is prepared to stand up against some dark and dangerous forces, or Hong Kong risks being relegated to a second-tier city in China, offering international shopping, spoilt harbour views and a few disappearing colonial experiences.

Yet, with so little time left, we still do not know the final line-up of candidates. The media, including this newspaper, has been assiduous in speculating about who might run and carrying interviews with those who have put themselves forward. But short interviews do not really allow anyone to assess a candidate, let alone judge how they will perform in the hot seat of power.

It is important to organise proper hustings for the election of Leung’s successor: systematically list the major issues facing Hong Kong; interview candidates at length; publish, compare and contrast their plans; seek expert views on potential black swans that might disrupt and test even the best plans; spark dialogue between candidates and the people at large – all of which will guide the electors to make a more considered choice.

Seven policy proposals for Hong Kong’s next chief executive

Am I joking or just being naive? This election is not about popular or even public choice. Barely 1,200 people can vote. The only vote that really counts is that of Xi Jinping (習近平), or the person he designates.
Anyone who has not slept through the past 20 years knows that Beijing is afraid of letting fully fledged democracy loose on its doorstep

Surely we should take with a giant pinch of salt reports suggesting that Beijing is afraid the winning candidate may struggle to get the 700 votes it believes is necessary for the next chief to have the authority to do the job? All it needs is for Xi to whisper who he favours and all but the diehard democrats will lend their support.

Advertisement

Anyone who has not slept through the past 20 years knows that Beijing is afraid of letting fully fledged democracy loose on its doorstep.

With good reason, you might say, given the antics of the pro-democracy gang of children in profaning their oath-taking as elected members of the Legislative Council. But let’s also not forget the bullying of the leading so-called pro-establishment figures.
Advertisement

Indeed, democracy itself has come under increasing questioning in its Western homeland, given the savagely flawed versions exhibited in voting in the US and the UK recently, with campaigns full of abuse, lies and half-truths.

No longer in thrall to Western democracy, Asia turns to technocrats for answers

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x